Episode 289 · 52 min
Stop Being Mr. Nice Guy: People Pleasing, Masculinity & Why Men Need More Than Therapy
What is Nice Guy Syndrome?
It is people pleasing driven by fear of rejection, where being liked becomes more important than being yourself. Dr. John Schinnerer talks with Marc Azoulay, founder of Men’s Therapy Online, about why the Nice Guy pattern is often an attempt to control how others feel about you, why it breeds resentment, and what a more honest version of masculinity looks like.
How to break the people-pleasing cycle
- Spot your covert contracts. Notice the unspoken deals: “If I am endlessly helpful, I will get love and affection in return.” Your partner never signed that contract.
- Say what you need out loud. Replace hinting and hoping with a direct request.
- Set boundaries and tolerate disagreement. Someone being disappointed in you is survivable.
- Watch for resentment. Suppressed anger and unexpressed needs boil over somewhere else.
- Get support that fits. Men’s groups, mentorship, coaching, and experiential work can complement traditional therapy.
Healthy masculinity in one question
Strength without domination, confidence without arrogance, independence without isolation. The test John and Marc return to: do you have the trait, or does the trait have you?
Episode notes
The Evolved Caveman Podcast | Dr. John Schinnerer with Marc Azoulay
Are you actually a nice guy—or just terrified of disappointing people? You say yes when you want to say no, avoid conflict, and put everyone else's needs first—yet feel exhausted and resentful. Welcome to Nice Guy Syndrome, where being liked becomes more important than being yourself.
Dr. Schinnerer joins Marc Azoulay, founder of Men's Therapy Online, to explore people pleasing, men's mental health, and emotionally mature masculinity. Sometimes being the Nice Guy isn't kindness—it's trying to control how others feel about you. The alternative isn't selfishness; it's respecting yourself as much as you respect others.
What You'll Learn
1. Nice Guy Syndrome — Fear of rejection, abandonment, and shame fuels people pleasing. We unpack "covert contracts": unspoken expectations that endless helpfulness will earn love and affection—without telling your partner about the deal.
2. Why Nice Guys Become Resentful — Suppressed anger, unexpressed needs, and weak boundaries create the relationship problems you're trying to avoid.
3. Breaking the People-Pleasing Cycle — Set boundaries, express needs, tolerate disagreement, and face rejection without becoming aggressive or unavailable. Replace covert contracts with honesty and accountability.
4. When Traditional Therapy Misses the Mark — Why can a man look successful yet feel numb? Men's groups, mentorship, coaching, and experiential work can complement traditional treatment.
5. Healthy Masculinity — Strength without domination, confidence without arrogance, independence without isolation. Do you have the trait—or does the trait have you?
6. Addiction, Divorce, and Identity — Alcohol, porn, gambling, and overwork can be ways to avoid uncomfortable emotions. Rebuilding after divorce takes more than a new partner.
7. The Future of Men's Work — What if men got support before hitting a breaking point? Community, mentorship, and practical emotional skills build stronger lives and relationships.
About Marc Azoulay
Marc founded Men's Therapy Online, offering counseling through licensed clinicians, men's groups, community, and wilderness retreats. His work draws on psychoanalysis, neuroscience, and Buddhism to help men break unconscious patterns.
Connect Like an Evolved Caveman
Explore Proxi He, an AI-powered coaching tool for men—practical, private, and available 24/7—for emotional awareness, boundaries, and stronger relationships.
More from Dr. John Schinnerer:
The Evolved Caveman — Emotional intelligence, masculinity, and personal growth.
Guide to Self — Emotional mastery and anger-management resources.
Love Isn't Enough — Relationship insights with Dr. Schinnerer and Joree Rose, LMFT.
Dig the Episode?
If this conversation made you realize you've spent half your life trying to be the guy everyone else wants you to be, share it with another man who needs to hear it.
And please follow, rate, and review The Evolved Caveman Podcast. It helps us reach more men who are ready to trade outdated masculine conditioning for greater confidence, connection, courage, and emotional freedom.
Remember: Being a good man doesn't mean being a Nice Guy. It means having the courage to be yourself while treating others with kindness and respect.
Episode transcript: Stop Being Mr. Nice Guy, with Marc Azoulay
Dr. John Schinnerer with Marc Azoulay · The Evolved Caveman. Transcript provided for reading, with speakers labeled, timestamps retained, and name spellings corrected.
Welcome and Guest Intro
Dr. John Schinnerer: [00:00:00] Hey, everybody. This is Dr. John, back with another episode of the Evolved Caveman podcast. Thank you for listening. Thank you for your attention. I'm thrilled to have with me here today Marc Azoulay Marc is the founder of Men's Therapy Online, a community and healing hub for men who want to get back on their feet or take their lives to the next level.
With the help of his team of licensed clinicians, he provides ongoing men's groups, individual counseling, and powerful wilderness retreats to his members. With a background in psychoanalysis, neuroscience, and Buddhism, Marc's able to help men uncover and destroy the unconscious barriers that hold them back.
His mission is to help men become the best version of themselves and truly show up for their lives, relationships, and community. Marc, welcome. Great to have you.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah, so happy to be on the show
Why Therapy Misses Men
Dr. John Schinnerer: So one of the things you said that was a little provocative was that traditional therapy frequently fails men.
And so coming from a therapist raises some [00:01:00] eyebrows, so let's start there. What are we getting wrong about men?
Marc Azoulay: Oh, so much. So much. I... So if I back it up we look at the history of psych- psychotherapy and certainly psychology, it was very male-dominated, right? You think of like- Yeah
Sigmund Freud, Carl Jung Adler, right? Like, all these kind of big-name dudes. And they... And that old school way, which I was trained in, actually works with men, so I'll come back around and say, you know- ... how that works. But recently, therapy has become extremely female-dominated, right? And not only that, there's nothing wrong with female therapists, obviously, but where it gets a little bit wonky is that most psychology students are females, right?
And most research that's being done that's informing modern methods is done on those students. So you basically have these methods that are being applied to men that were formed in the lab with basically, sophomore and junior college-old women, which is really different compared to somebody in their 40s and 50 that's going to therapy for the first time, so there's a huge disconnect in the way that the field is moving, in that it's not taking into consideration [00:02:00] a couple key things, right? I'll go through them. The first is how men experience, process, and communicate emotions. You know- ... if you think of the classic psychotherapy question, you know "How does that make you feel," right?
Most men aren't gonna be able to answer that question. They're not gonna say- ... "oh, I feel frustrated or upset or resentful." We're just not trained to do that, but we're gonna say stuff like, "I feel like beating the shit out of that person," or, "I feel like killing myself," or, "I feel pissed and I wanna go punch a wall."
We talk through actions and behaviors, but I've seen so many, unskilled psychotherapists try to really hammer home those feeling words, and what it does is it pisses off dudes, right? Because it's- Well, it
Dr. John Schinnerer: makes us feel like failures, yeah.
Marc Azoulay: Immediately. Or
Dr. John Schinnerer: idiots.
Marc Azoulay: Idiots, immediately. Yes. It makes us feel like we're failing at something.
How Men Connect Differently
Marc Azoulay: S- similarly just the idea, the, the current format of psychotherapy, which is a face-to-face conversation for, call it, 50 minutes, right? Talking about your emotions. Research, modern research shows that is not how men connect. I'm sure you talked about on your show, right?
Men connect side by side working on a, on an [00:03:00] objective. And my field, I have to apologize for it, we have said that is a lesser form of connection than the face-to-face connection. So if that... If you're coming in with that assumption, you're saying, "Okay, the way that you're talking to me," "the way that you wanna connect, the things that you value and care about are all unacceptable when it comes to the therapeutic dogma."
Yes. And that turns a lot of men away.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah I agree. I think that therapy isn't made for men, like the public school system the educational system. Partly because school requires us to sit down, shut up, raise our hand when we have something to say- Yes ... and be polite and demure, and that's not really how we're wired generally.
But, as far as the research goes, i- originally the research was done on white college-age men. So are you saying that now it's shifting more towards college-age women?
Marc Azoulay: Yes. Yeah. So most of the research done at the university level is done on psychology students, yeah. And I remember when I went to school that was part of graduating- Yeah
is that you had to be a, you had to be a subject, test subject- Be a guinea pig ... for I think it was, like, yeah, six hours or something you had to [00:04:00] participate- Yeah ... in studies, right? So if that is their main pool and they're pulling from people getting psychology degrees, that's a vast majority of them are women, right?
Yeah. So that, that pool is shifting. It's not that there's no men but it's m- way more heavily female than male at this point.
The Numb Successful Guy
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah and one of the things that's really fascinated me about what you've set up is this kind of ecology of- men's experiences or development for men. So here, let me give you a scenario.
So there's- imagine there's a successful 40-year-old guy listening to this podcast right now. His life is pretty good. Life isn't falling apart. He's got a job, maybe a wife, couple kids, some friends, but he's numb. He's going through the motions- Wow ... drinking a little too much, disappearing into his phone.
He knows something is missing, but he doesn't think he needs therapy because nothing's technically wrong. So what would you like him to understand, and what should he do next?
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. Yeah, so first, if he came in I'd like to ask him questions, right? I'd be curious about, one, what did he give up to get to where he was today?[00:05:00]
I think a lot of men, especially in that age group, call them Gen Xers, maybe young- ... Boomers, had to sacrifice a lot to buy into this narrative, right? Which they needed to. There's no- Yeah ... no shame there, right? It's freaking hard out there. The economy's tough. You gotta practice and you gotta really work on your job.
You have to level up, and that means probably abandoning a lot of your dreams, so a lot of these guys are waking up in their 40s, their 50s, around that midlife area, and they're like, "Man," "okay, I did well at this game, but in order to play the game, I had to cut off parts of myself." And what that might look like is ev- you know, creative pursuit an athletic pursuit relationships, especially with other men, like just friends.
A sense of feeling dangerous and feeling capable in the world. A lot of men, we're not meant to be completely intellectual creatures. We're very physical, embodied creatures. The name of your podcast Evolved Caveman. Yeah. We still are cavemen. We need to know that we're strong, that we can defend ourselves, that we're able to, do difficult things.
A lot of men give those up because they focus entirely in the intellectual and career realm, so I'd ask him "What did you give up?" "What parts did [00:06:00] you leave bes- behind?" And now, if this guy has some level of success, hopefully he can afford to slow down a little bit, yeah. To slow down, to reawaken parts of his life, whether that be hobbies or interests, whether that be an emotional depth, whether that be spirituality. Whatever draws him. And what I would say to him is I think psychotherapy, yeah, there's that stigma where people think, okay, you have to be like, crazy or an alcoholic or have a real problem, be on medication, right- in order to go to psychotherapy. What we're trying to reframe it as is it's like just understanding your own instruction manual, understanding who you are, where you came from, what your past was, what you care about, so you get to know yourself- Yeah ... so you can be a better man, right? So you can be that parent that, to yourself that you never had, right?
You can be- ... that best friend to yourself that you never had. You can live a life that's fully aligned with your values and work your way up that Maslow's pyramid to self-actualization. So therapy, especially for that successful dude, it can be more of a self-inquiry process, right? It doesn't have to be like healing, right?
Doesn't have to be like, solving all your old [00:07:00] wounds and coming and crying, in public. A lot of guys think that's what it is. But it can be- Yeah ... something that's much more introspective than that, and more practical.
Coaching vs Validation Therapy
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah and I think that's why I've tended towards coaching versus therapy- Yeah
in my career, is I think men just resonate more with coaching, and they wanna be... They want someone that's gonna be a little more direct with them, not someone that's just- Yeah ... "Gee, how do you feel about that?" And then we just sit and spin on how you feel, and they don't really get anywhere to go from that.
It's not... I don't think most men are process-oriented.
No. I think more action or results-oriented. But I've seen that guy a lot- Yeah ... throughout my career of just this guy that's been successful, that did it all according to the bill of goods he was sold, according to society.
Go to school, get good grades, get a job, make money, make... have the family, and then you focus on work, retire at 65, and then you'll be happy. And so many of them... And I... a lot of guys that are worth a lot of money at, you know, 40, 45, 50, 55 that wake up and just say, "This isn't doing [00:08:00] it for me."
Yeah. And what else is there? And I like the idea that we spend, the first half of our lives proving ourselves and trying to make a mark in the world, and the second half of life is more, "Okay, now that I've proven myself, now what?"
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: What do I actually care about? And I think part of it's rediscovering what we truncated or cleaved off of ourselves or our psyche back at the age of five, let's say.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah 100%. And I guess to go to your first point, I think you're apt, right? We- what I call them in the content that I make is a validation therapist, right? A therapist just agrees with you.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Marc Azoulay: And again, that- that's what we were taught. That's what I was taught in therapy school was coping, right?
That it's all about coping and emotional support. And again, when you see with women, when you do emotionally support them, and you validate them and you listen to them and you say, "You know what? That's so hard," they actually get better. It- ... it works for them, right? And you probably see this when you talk about relationships, right?
If you just support the women in your life, listen, don't try to fix them, don't give them advice they will grow in ways that surprise you. It's very counterintuitive to the male brain. But to your [00:09:00] point exactly the way that we train our people is to be more confrontational, right? Yeah.
Is to hold guys accountable. Is to have them, state their values so that we can then check them on those values when they make decisions. Because, it's not about building safety, which is again a very feminine idea. Especially white middle-aged dudes in America are the safest people on planet Earth.
We don't need more safety, right? What we need is respect, and I think the coaching model has that built in. I think what we try to do at MTO, we have that built in where we're trying to have our clients respect us and we respect them, and that means confrontation a lot of the time, right? That means healthy, grounded challenge and conflict.
And again the, the current training on psychotherapy is just validate, support, cope. Don't make change, just cope with your life the way it is, right? Accept it- Yeah ... rather than trying to- Yeah ... improve yourself, and I think most men- Well- ... we wanna improve ourselves.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And I think of it I had a big awakening, I don't know, 30 years ago where, I was trained in traditional developmental psychology.
Yeah. And to me, the last 100 years of psychology has been all about [00:10:00] how do we fix what's broken-
...
Dr. John Schinnerer: In the human psyche. Depression, anxiety, ADHD, trauma, whatever it is. And I was like, "Okay, that's cool." I need to know that for my clients and for myself at the time. And then I got into positive psychology, and then it's all about, how do we reach our potential?
And, how do we cultivate more frequent positive emotions? How do we find meaning and purpose? And how do we find and create positive, supportive relationships? And so there was something really- I don't know, eye-opening, cloud parting for me where it was like, oh, shit, so this is the next level of where we're going.
So what you're talking about is, how do we cope with our life as it is, but then the not- the other part is how do we figure out where we wanna go? Yes. I remember when I came out of my divorce, I don't know, 15-plus years ago, I didn't even know what I wanted, liked, or needed.
Because I had given everything that I had to my family. And, for instance, just getting dinner was like, where do you all wanna go for dinner? 'Cause I don't care that much. I'll eat [00:11:00] whatever. And it's harder to find a, suitable restaurant choice for four kids than it is for me.
And along the way you just lose pieces of yourself. And I would say the good news is that it's an enjoyable process to rediscover who you are and what you like and what your needs are.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Stop Playing Nice Guy
Dr. John Schinnerer: So speaking of that, so that's a, a good segue into this. One of your ideas that you talk about is Mr.
Nice Guy.
And kinda stop playing Mr. Nice Guy. So explain to the listener th- this concept of the nice guy, if you would.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah, so there's a couple things. But first, yeah, like coming on what you said about, it's easier for you to not have needs, especially when you're providing for other people.
That in some ways is the core part of the nice guy, and it's really common. And I don't wanna demonize that. You'll hear a lot of speakers that say that like there's a problem with that, like self-sacrifice, because when you look at male relationships and, if you're, I don't know, if you...
And, or if you play any kind of sport or you're any kind of male hierarchy you know this to be true. What you wanna do is not be a liability,
Dr. John Schinnerer: yeah.
Marc Azoulay: And if you're in a healthy [00:12:00] hierarchy, which there are plenty of them- Yeah ... it's not about being the top, right? It's not about being the alpha, right?
I think the unhealthy, toxic ones it's about being the alpha. But it's really about just like not being a problem, so if you are at a, a good Brazilian jujitsu gym, the idea is hey, even if you're a beginner, as long as you're respectful of the guys that are higher on the hierarchy, as long as clean off your equipment, as long as you know your lane, you're welcome with open arms.
But if you're like out there loudmouthin' and you're like shit talkin' the, the coaches, and you're like m- throwing your shit all over the gym and making a clutter, like then that's how you actually lose status in a healthy- ... hierarchy, right? Because you're a liability. So there's a lot of this in- internal male thing when it comes to groups of don't be a problem, right?
Don't be difficult. Don't be bringing the group down. Yeah. And we need that evolutionarily because if there's people bringing the group down the group is gonna fail and then the hunt, if you're hunting an elk in this metaphor is not gonna work, right? If you have someone- that's just like yakking and just like scares the deer away it doesn't work out. So the, the idea here is that it comes from a place that's evolutionarily n- like a [00:13:00] necessity, right? Of like I'm going to provide, I'm going to be only giving positive value, and I'm not gonna be taking any value.
The problem with that is that with guys that have been rewarded for that because our culture does reward that whether it's in a- ... family environment, as a child in a work environment, being easy you often get rewarded because you're, again- ... you're not a problem. The problem is that a lot of these guys can't turn it off.
And to your point partially because life is more complicated, partially because we live longer in some ways, right? If you do that for a long enough time, you lose who you are, right? Your, your identity then becomes, okay, I'm the easy one, right? I'm the guy that gets everything done.
I'm the dependable one. I'm the one that says yes to everything. I'm the guy that people call when they need something. And when I say this out, out loud, like I said, none of those are bad. I think being dependable and reliable are awesome masculine val- masculine values. Yeah. Again, the, the downside is not being able to turn it off and doing it to a place where you overcommit, and then you're actually not fulfilling those values, right?
That's where when it starts to become a problem, is that you're saying yes [00:14:00] to everything- Yeah ... and if if you're honest with yourself, you're actually, you're not that dependable because maybe you're half-assing something, or you're not taking care of yourself, so you can't show up in the way that you want, right?
Stuff starts to fall apart. You also see with nice guys there tends to be a not so nice side of them because the human psyche is not that black and white, right? So there has to be- ... another side. The other side for those guys, most commonly what I see, especially in the modern era, is porn, porn addiction, actually.
Oh, okay. But usually there's some kind of addictive behavior, some kind of self-harm behavior, some kind of escapism behavior. Sometimes they might be, dismissive or even rude or God forbid abusive with the people closest to them. Because all that- energy, all that aggression, all that resentment, all that stuff that they're cutting off that they're truncating from themselves- Yep
boils over somewhere else. So- Yeah,
Covert Contracts and Resentment
Dr. John Schinnerer: One of the things... Sorry to interrupt, but one of the things that I see is that accumulation of resentment- Yeah ... in nice guys and I saw it myself a decade or two ago. Yeah. And so you just sacrifice yourself, self-sacrifice, give pieces of yourself, and there's these little pieces of [00:15:00] resentment that accrue until finally so many accrue that you just go volcanic and lose your temper.
Marc Azoulay: Yes. Yes, and Dr. Glover talks about that right in his book, No More Mr. Nice Guy. He calls it a covert contract. Yeah. And that's why the nice guy is not so nice, because you're doing these things and, again, if you ask a nice guy... Again, I was a recovering... I'm a nice guy, I'm a recovering nice guy. I would say oh, it's because I care, because I wanna be dependable, because I'm trying to be a better man.
I'd have all these really altruistic reasons- Yeah ... for doing stuff. But if I'm honest- Yeah,
Dr. John Schinnerer: the intentions are honorable ...
Marc Azoulay: they're honorable, but they're fake, right? If I'm being honest, I wanted something from that person, right? Yep. I wanted- You wanted
something
Dr. John Schinnerer: in return.
Marc Azoulay: I want something in return.
It's not altruistic at all. It's extremely transactional, right? If it was- Yeah ... a woman I was dating, I wanted to get laid, right? If it was my friends, I wanted them to show up in the exact same way that I did when I need them, if it was a client, I wanted them to pay me and refer more people to me, right?
I was doing it ex- intentionally, right? I wanted something from this behavior, status, money- Yeah ... love, belonging, all, all that stuff that humans want, but I wasn't communicating it.
[00:16:00] So I would be pissed off when I wouldn't get it because they didn't... They were playing a game that they didn't know they were playing.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, which is always dangerous. And one of the... i've been working on a book, and one of the lines that's come out of the book that I love is, "Do you have the trait or does the trait have you?" And so I agree exactly with your point, right? The problem... It- it's not a problem with being self-sacrificing.
It's a problem when you can't turn it off. And like for instance, there's a difference between a man who can be stoic and a man who can only be stoic.
And so I like the distinction just simply of do you have the trait or does the trait have you? Because what I'm shooting for with my clients is greater psychological flexibility and choice, and I want them to have tools and different gears, access to all parts of themselves that they can bring to different situations based on the need of the situation versus just stoicism or self-sacrifice or self-reliance, for example.
Marc Azoulay: 100%,
Dr. John Schinnerer: yeah. What are your thoughts on that? I mean-
Marc Azoulay: Oh, definitely.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah ... 'cause I think we're agreeing a lot on this.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah, definitely agree 100%. I mean-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Which maybe we should disagree [00:17:00] more. I don't know.
Marc Azoulay: But, yeah, I use the toolbox metaphor the same thing, right? It's like- Yeah ... if you got really good at making a hammer, right, and all you have is a hammer, then everything's a nail, yeah. If your answer to everything is stoicism, hardness, and aggression, then you're gonna start to see that in the world more so and you're gonna be doing that, a- and I think, as a kinda like spinoff, when we talk about emotionality with men, I have a metaphor I talk about with this where I think when most guys hear, "Be more emotional," right, which they sometimes hear from the women in their life- they think "Okay, so you want me to cry on the couch and be, like, a sad sack of shit and just hate my life? No thank you," right? Yeah. And the women don't want that either. But I think as men- Yeah ... that's what we think of when we think of an emotional man, right? Or someone that's gets angry and beats their kids, which we also don't want.
But when I think of emotional man I direct them to people like Martin Luther King, right? Julius Caesar. Dwayne The Rock Johnson actually or Arnold Schwarzenegger actually-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, Shohei Ohtani comes to mind- Yes ... in terms of someone that can manage their...
Tiger Woods come to, came to mind at least earlier in his career. Yes. But he had great... Both of them have great ability to manage their emotions- Yes ... under pressure, and it's the under pressure- Yes ... [00:18:00] part that's really key, I would say.
Marc Azoulay: Yes. Yeah. A- and I would say that they, also they manage them and to build on that, leverage them- to do great things, right? So the example I use is you have a funeral, right? And the stoic man that we're talking about he's trying to sit in the back and not cry and not show emotion and just lock it down, and in that he's disconnecting from everyone else in the congregation, right?
The emotional man or the healthy emotional man gets up on the stage and gives a powerful eulogy, right? That it comes from an emotional place. That maybe- ... he even tears up a little bit, maybe his voice cracks, but he's using his emotion through the art of oration, through speaking.
Yeah. And he moves the room to tears, right? Yeah, and he connects with everyone in the room. That's the emotion that we want. Exactly. Yeah. It's connection. It's power. It's everything, right? That's what-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, because one of the things I've thought a lot about is I really think that emotions are the social glue between us.
It's what connects us. It's not... i, my first 30 years I was highly intellectual. I was in my head, right? I was Descartes' wet dream, right? I think therefore I am. [00:19:00] And the, the problem with that is it doesn't connect with anyone.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: I mean- It doesn't connect in a deep and meaningful way, let me put it that way.
Whereas if I can access all my emotions and use them skillfully in different scenarios in order to connect, empathize, validate, that's where I think real connection comes from. That's where leadership comes from. That's where presence comes from
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. I, f- 100%, right? I think tho- those are the universal feelings that you see it in, you know, art, music, culture, across all generations, right?
They're just ways of communicating and evoking emotion in other people- Yeah ... right? That is that human, animal, like, primal stuff. Whereas, yeah, like intellectual exchange is just like data exchange, which is- ... stimulating, right? And like- Can be good ... you can get stuff done, but it's not connective.
You're not gonna really remember- Yeah ... it in the same way than if you really felt something with somebody else- ... right?
Dr. John Schinnerer: So let me ask you this. Let's say there's a listener and he's listening to this, and he's like maybe I'm a nice guy. Like, how do I know?" Yeah. How would you [00:20:00] lear- how would you teach someone to figure out the extent to which they're a nice guy?
Marc Azoulay: Oh, yeah. I think it's we're talking about the covert contracts. Nice guys think that the world is unfair. So if that's, if that is a, a thing- Oh, it is ... yeah. But they're like- ... really personally invested in that, right?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. They're taking it personally, the unfairness.
Marc Azoulay: Taking it personally.
If you keep thinking that, that's my number one kind of diagnosis. If people are like, "This person was unfair to me. This was unfair. I did so much work at my job. I didn't get a promotion." "That's unfair. My spouse is being unfair to me. My kids are unfair to me." If it's, if you have this like such a rigid view of justice, that is a really interesting way to see that you have a transactional view of the world, right?
Because to your point, the world is unfair, right? The world is not 50/50. That's impossible. Right? But I think someone that has an evolved sense of the way that culture works is there are times where you give more, there's those times that you receive more, right? There are also these, you know- Yeah
get, not to get too political, but there's oppressive powers that are pushing people down. [00:21:00] Those are constants, right? It's a much more nuanced take on the way that society and relationships work. Yeah. But if you're stuck in this very black and white transactional "Hey, if I put in this combination, I get to open up the safe and I get what I want," that, one, I think that's it's just a sign of immaturity, and two, shows that nice guy pattern because that's the root of it.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. A- it's interesting, your point, 'cause it, it makes me think of relationships and the tit for tat mentality. Yes. If I do this for you, you do this for me. Yes. With, again, it's an unspoken contract. The I was thinking about this earlier and I was thinking about sort of the distinction between healthy kindness, people pleasing, and that nice guy covert contract, and I think the healthy kindness is I'm doing this because I choose to.
The people pleasing is I'm doing this because I'm afraid of what happens if I don't. And the nice guy kind of covert contract is I'm doing this because whether I admit it or not, I expect something back.
Marc Azoulay: Yes. Yeah, at some point you're gonna pay me back or I'm gonna get the reward.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Marc Azoulay: Again, if I... And again, men think of women this way, right? If I can just [00:22:00] figure out the code, figure out the password, right? If I put in the right password, I get what I want. I think for a lot of nice guys that's sex, frankly, right? Yeah. And then on a deeper level, that's like love, acceptance, belonging, right?
But they're trying to crack the code- Rather than connect with that person.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah and some of... i've I've also thought about how that nice guy mask functions to protect pieces of ourselves and I think some of that deep logic underneath it might be things like, if I disappoint people, I may lose belonging or they may kick me out of the tribe, so to speak.
If someone's angry with me- Yeah ... I'm unsafe. If my partner's unhappy, I have to fix it. If I express a need, I'm selfish. If I say no, I'm a bad man. Those are some of those hidden rules that I think we gotta excavate and figure out, what's going on here? Like why am I doing this?
And then the other... let me ask you this.
Low Self Worth and the Hole
Dr. John Schinnerer: To what extent do you think self-worth, or more specifically low self-worth, ties into people-pleasing or being a, a nice guy?
Marc Azoulay: Oh, I think, yeah, I think it's the same thing, right? I mean- Yeah ... we talk... just what you're [00:23:00] saying, right? When you talk about those deeper needs like love, belonging, acceptance, when you continue the thought, it's like, okay then that mean that person must feel unloved, that they don't belong, and that they're not accepted.
Yeah. And what I find for a lot of nice guys and, to tie back to your midlife, straw man client we're talking about here, there's often one area that they are truly insecure about. And listeners- ... you... There's probably one that comes to mind, and I'll talk about for me.
From my nice guy thing, I was really overweight, right? Now I'm great. I have go to the gym, do CrossFit. It's awesome, right? But I was really overweight, and because I was overweight, I felt that I was unlovable. So I would do all these things. I would spend a bunch of money on people.
I would always be reliable. I would listen to women and validate them as much as possible, right? I would be an extremely generous lover. I would do all these things because I felt like if I did all that, maybe it could've, it could overcome the self-hatred I felt for being fat.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Marc Azoulay: And that's not how it works.
That's stupid, right? But until you, until I went to therapy, until I figured it out and realized that no, the way to get over hating my [00:24:00] weight is to get in shape, right? Yeah. Actually fix the problem, then that confidence is there, right? I think of... I use a metaphor of, the bucket with a hole in it, right?
Yeah. Again, listeners, think about it. You probably know what your hole is. It's not a surprise. It might be... Again, it might be your fitness. It might be your financial situation. It might be your sexual prowess. It might be a regret or a trauma that you've had when you were a child that you never quite closed the loop.
But there's a hole in your bucket. And you can fill it with as much money and power and success and status and whatever, but if it's draining constantly you're never gonna feel like you're a full bucket, yeah. And I think most guys are like that. Most people are like that.
We have things that we would much rather double down on what works rather than confront the scary thing and actually fix the hole in the bucket. And, you know-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, I, I-
Marc Azoulay: Yeah ...
Dr. John Schinnerer: I think for me, some of my issues that drove that were low self-worth, which is why I asked the question. And I think I didn't wanna disappoint people.
Yeah. I think I wanted to be liked by everyone, which is fucking impossible. And yeah I think those were some of the things [00:25:00] that led to me really not having the courage to speak up for myself- ... and set and enforce boundaries, and to stop letting my guilt run the show.
Guilt and Shame Reframed
Dr. John Schinnerer: Which, I've talked to a lot of people about guilt, and what are your thoughts on this?
If, I think I, I see guilt these days as existing on a 1 to 10 scale. I see most emotions this way. But I think we're born with, I would say to some degree, an innate sense of guilt, and some of our sense of guilt is turned up just naturally too high. Or maybe it was, it became that way because of what our parents did, how they, how we were parented.
Yeah. But I've talked to a lot of people who their guilt is a 9 or 10 on that scale, and they feel guilty when they haven't done anything wrong. Have you have you had experience with that with yourself or clients?
Marc Azoulay: Oh, yeah. For sure. It's just what you're saying. It's I think a lack of, emotional parenting, a lack of context.
What a lot of parents will do is that they'll punish a kid for something wrong, which is, you probably do at the beginning, but then they [00:26:00] never come back around and explain why it was wrong.
Or if the parent, you know, got triggered and they overreacted, they never come back and say, "Hey, you know what?
Yeah, what you did was wrong, but I think I went a little bit too hard on you." So you have all these open loops that the child brain has, and that becomes their internal guilt meter, yeah. And again I'll be a little provocative 'cause I think most therapists think that guilt and shame are 100% toxic.
I think that they are critical- ... and I think that they are good information, for people to have. It's just about do- does it turn into self-harm? Which I think is what you're talking about- Yeah ... right? Does it go
Dr. John Schinnerer: too
Marc Azoulay: far?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Okay g- so I have a question since you say guilt and shame can be positive.
I ab- absolutely agree with guilt. Guilt- ... I think is a healthy emotion. It, if I wrong you I pull back and I think about, "Geez, what did I do to piss off Marc?" And then I go, "Oh, yeah," and then I come back and I apologize. That's ideally what guilt drives us to do. It's a boomerang effect.
I can't come up with a positive for shame. Oh. I- shame is the belief that we are, to me, the belief that we are unworthy of love, connection, and belonging, and I can see back in tribal times, [00:27:00] some people have made the argument it was needed to keep our behavior in line to keep the tribe safe.
But what's your positive for shame?
Marc Azoulay: Yeah, so for shame, I think it's you feel shame when you're betraying your own values, right? When you do something that you are ashamed of, you're like, "Yeah, I really shouldn't have done that," right? The person that I wanna be or the person that I say I am is incongruent with my behavior.
Shame vs Guilt Signals
Marc Azoulay: So again, I don't think that it means that you're unlovable or it means that you hate yourself or that you're unworthy, I think that's what it feels like, but I think the message underneath is like, "Man, I betrayed myself." Whereas guilt, like you said, guilt is focused on somebody else "Hey, I pissed you off."
Maybe a misunderstanding. Maybe it was malicious, right? Maybe there was something that, that, that crossed the wires, but it's relational. Where shame is with yourself, so the idea that hey, I say to everybody and I... Or I believe myself. I won't say I say to everybody 'cause it's relational.
I believe myself that honesty is very important, right? And then, oh my God, I just caught myself lying. I feel shame because I s- say that I'm an honest person. I value honesty, and here I [00:28:00] am betraying my values. So again- Yeah ... it doesn't mean that you're inherently unworthy, which again, I think it feels that way, but if you can get through the storm of the feeling and go down to that nugget of okay, what actually triggered the shame, I think there can be something actionable there, because again you... My idea is that you betrayed part of yourself. You were acting in alignment with the person you wanted.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
When Past Shame Triggers
Dr. John Schinnerer: See it's fascinating to me because I see shame as more, originating when the present activates the past.
And, so for instance, I, if you would've asked me five, six, seven years ago, "John, do you deal with any shame?"
I would've been like, "No." And then I found some. And, it would come up when I would disappoint or hurt my wife, and we'd get in a disagreement, and then she's explaining to me, how much I hurt her or what I did wrong. And after about 10, 15 minutes, I found I would go to shame, and the only way I recognized that was by identifying the thoughts that existed for maybe a minute.
Which were things like, "I guess I'm just no good at this relationship stuff," or, "She'd be better off without me." And so it's interesting 'cause I think that was [00:29:00] tapping into stuff that took place back when I was three, four, five years old, basic- more- m- more or less with my mom. And so then it brings up this belief that maybe I'm just better off alone."
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: So slightly different take on shame.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. Could be, we could be mixing definitions or splitting hairs here. Yeah.
Using Shame as Feedback
Marc Azoulay: But I guess to- if we're gonna keep threading on it, my, my reframe for you would be, like, maybe you need to learn some relationship skills, right? The, the, the trauma piece that got triggered, thing about your mom, the thing about, I don't know your past, but if there was- abuse or trauma or PTSD, like, all of that is unnecessary, right? But the original thing of man, the way I'm operating this relationship is not how I wanna operate this relationship. Yeah. The way that I'm working... and the nugget is yeah, you may need to build some skills, right? Go to therapy, go to coaching, have better conversations with your wife, the... to c- use my example of being, like, overweight and fat, right? I was ashamed of my body, right? Yeah. I hated my body. And that spun off into trauma of being bullied or feeling like I didn't belong and all that stuff. That is not necessary, [00:30:00] right? But the part of hey, my emotional system is telling me, "Pay attention to this," pay attention to this. Pay attention to your relationship with your body, right? You don't like it. Don't ignore it. But what I did especially early on, is I would ignore it. I would get drunk, right? I would smoke weed. I would numb that feeling 'cause I didn't wanna feel ashamed. And of course it got worse.
Yeah. But the minute... Or not the minute. The, it was many years. But as I learned to confront that feeling, tolerate that feeling, and, you don't feel shame with your body more so than when you start going to the gym and I'm on the treadmill and I'm, like, dying at a low pace and I feel even more ashamed because I'm like, "Man, I'm weak, I'm fat, I'm slow," all these things are coming up.
But it's about feeling it and then progressing through it, right? So I think the shame is, it's a signal, it's a dramatic signal, to your point. Yeah. And the, we can cut the drama off so that we can actually act on the signal. But I do think there's a nugget there.
There's there's a nugget- Well- ... of truth there.
Men and Emotional Avoidance
Dr. John Schinnerer: And I like your point about tolerating the feeling- Yeah ... because I think, confronting the feeling, tolerating the feeling and now I'm just talking about emotions in general, because I think men have a [00:31:00] hard time. We're afraid of emotion.
And then we have a hard time tolerating them when they come up. And I've talked to men, they're like yeah, but if I go there, it's like scratching a scab. The scab's gonna come off, it's gonna start bleeding, and the bleeding's never gonna stop." Another... he's talking about sadness, right?
Or, grief or anguish. And the fear is that the emotion's gonna overtake me, overwhelm me, and there's no off nozzle Have you seen much of that? The-
Marc Azoulay: Oh, for sure. For sure. And I, and that's why I advocate for men to work with male therapists or male coaches because I think that is the... I think you just nailed the male emotional experience.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Marc Azoulay: Is like we are afraid, and I think there are a couple of reasons, and I'll go into them. But the first one is that we know that our emotions can be violent. And m- men, almost all men, including myself, I think most men have had an experience with violence. Yeah. Either it's something that we've done that we are ashamed or guilty about, or something's been done to us.
Like, when men get emotional, we get dangerous, right? An angry man, a sad [00:32:00] man even a super joyous man can be dangerous. And in a way that, that women can't quite be, right? We can get really violent, and we all know that. Inherently- Yeah ... we know that, right? Similarly, we're under a lot of pressure, so if we're crying on the couch for freaking three days, we know our life is not gonna be able to support that, we gotta go to a job. We gotta take care of our kids. We gotta do our shit, right? So in that way, they're seen as obstacles of... And a lot of men treat it that way, right? When I talked about my shame about my body, I saw it as an obstacle. Okay, I need to kill the shame so I can get back to work, right?
I need to kill my sadness, whether that be through drugs, alcohol, porn, whatever. Silence the alarm and then get back to work. The problem is if you keep doing that, you get what you talked about. You get this kind of pressure cooker experience where- Yeah ... because you've never really dealt with it it's, the next time it comes, it's stronger and stronger.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And you mentioned another trap there, the productivity trap, right? Yeah. Where... and I remember years ago trying to achieve my way out of my depression.
Marc Azoulay: Yes.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yes. If I'm doing all this, if I'm all this, how could I possibly be depressed?
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And the problem is you can't run faster than yourself.
I, and I think [00:33:00] that's, many of us will try and achieve our way out of these uncomfortable feelings. But yeah it's fascinating, and I have such compassion for men because I, I think we have cut off two-thirds of the emotional spectrum-
...
Dr. John Schinnerer: In ourselves in an effort to belong, in an effort to be part of the tribe with other men or other young men at the time.
Marc Azoulay: And it's just sad because it's just this like, it's a very Western American culture thing, right? It's very cowboy, 1950s culture.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And,
Marc Azoulay: you know-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Individualistic, yeah.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah, individualistic culture, being the stoic man that has the answer to everything. But if you look at male culture throughout history, men have always been in groups.
There have always been things like, church communities or fraternal organizations or men's lodges in indigenous communities and a lot of ritual and spirituality that, infused men's lives. They gave us permission and instruction on how to be emotional. And American culture has gutted all of that.
Yeah. It's all just cosplay and facsimile and fake at this point. So I think men are really struggling, but I don't think that's masculine. I think- ... I [00:34:00] think that's very new, right? It's very new. It's less than 100 years old- Yeah ... this, this performance that I think so much of us have been doing.
Rebuilding Healthy Masculinity
Dr. John Schinnerer: So let's flip the script in terms of what do you see as a more positive definition of masculinity? What do you see as, like where are we going to? Where are we heading?
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. Yeah. So I think I'll talk about the reason and then I'll say what kind of our, my values are. The, the reason is I think because of feminism, which again is a great thing, and also not new, right?
Women have been working for most of human civilization. It was again a very like 1950s, 1940s idea that women don't work, right? But if you look at most societies, women are always doing handicrafts, agriculture, raising children, selling food. There were merchants. Like women were doing shit all the time, again this is some American thing. So now that women are... don't need men to survive, right? We're being called to this more emotional, spiritual way of being again, right? Because before the setup was that like, okay, if you do provide enough, if you have enough money [00:35:00] you can get a family, you can get a child, you can get all this stuff- because the way that women were oppressed is like you can, they don't need, they don't do any of that, right? So it was a very binary system. Now we're being called to actually go back to, in some ways the way that we were, which is a more unified person, right? A person that is more focused on belonging, on spirituality, on connection, on legacy.
So the, the values that we have at MTO, and I'll pause after I say them and you can, if you have any questions, is strength, honor, courage and mastery. Those are our four, right? That's our definition of modern masculinity is pursuing those values, and the flavor doesn't matter. Again, I think that's what American culture gets wrong of being like, okay, you got to be into cars and guns and the gym.
No the f- the fl- that's just veneer, right? I'm talking about values, talking about who you are on a deep level, right? Strength, courage, honor and mastery are what we are trying to imbue in the guys that come through our program.
Strength Across Domains
Dr. John Schinnerer: So break down strength for me because I can t- I can take that several different directions.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. And it goes all the different directions, right? So strength is [00:36:00] across every domain, right? So physical strength we do believe is important, I think having a good relationship with your physicality- ... whether that be being a, a strength athlete, an endurance athlete, flexible, being a, a yoga master- being a dance master, right? Like any kind of strength, doesn't matter, right? But it's the idea of building physical strength in your body. I think when you see a man that is strong you get that feeling of okay, that is like more of a man in some ways- ... than someone who is not strong, right? But there's also emotional strength, right?
So I talked about that example of the, the dude at the funeral, right? Someone that can go up during an emotionally charged moment, give a powerful eulogy, that's emotional strength, right? There's also mental strength which is, which a lot of guys do have, which is like discipline, willpower, being able to work long hours, being able to solve complicated problems, right?
Like being strong in that mental world. And the last one is spiritual strength- ... so being able to surrender when necessary, being able to have wisdom and know when things are out of your control or versus in your control, being able to give advice and mentor people younger than you, right? [00:37:00] That is also very critical, right?
And being able to connect with something higher than yourself and let yourself go into ecstatic experiences. So strength is every domain. But you can tell that there is a hierarchy 'cause men are hierarchical and that's okay, right? You can be stronger or weaker in any category, right?
And the pursuit of strength across all categories makes a better man, in our opinion.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah it makes me think of-- I like this idea of let's look at strength on a one to 10 scale, right? Yeah. And if we throw the idea of flexibility or psychological flexibility into it, then you get the possibility of y- yeah, 'cause I wanna be strong.
I wanna be physically strong. Yeah. I wanna be emotionally strong, I wanna be mentally strong, spiritually strong, relationally strong. And yet there's also moments where I wanna let that guard down and relax into Let's say weakness- ... as just the opposite of strength, but I would... Tenderness, nurturing, care.
And I... So maybe you put that into emotionally strong.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: But it's interesting 'cause I want the flexibility to [00:38:00] be able to move the dial within these spectrums. Like self-reliance, right? Like self-reliance in general, great value.
I can get behind that. The problem is if you think of it on a one to 10 scale, most men will take it and peg it at a 10.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And we're so self-reliant that we can't h- ask for help when we've broken a leg or cut off a finger. I'm- ... a little bit extreme, you've... I've seen guys like this, that smash a hand in the field and they're like no, I'm just gonna tape it up and we're gonna... I'm gonna get back on the tractor."
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And so I think, to have some flexibility there of, yeah, self-reliance is great, and I also need the flexibility to know when I need to ask for help and to be able to give myself permission to ask for help and support.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. So I would say like from our definition, that's not strong.
That's maybe like tough or rigid, and I think we were talking about that spiritual dimension, right? I think one of the highest spiritual values is humility, which is exactly- ... what you're talking about, is having... and you can be good at humility and bad at humility, right? So I think if you have- spiritual strength, you're able to be humble. You're able to ask for help. You're [00:39:00] able to surrender, right? Which again- Yeah ... it doesn't feel like weakness. It feels like surrender. It feels like letting go, that's a spiritual strength category. You... So it... I don't think it's about not needing anything.
Again I think that's like very much like American culture. But I think strength is it's like capacity, right? So if, physical metaphor is the easiest, right? If you are strong physically, you can lift a lot of weight, and sometimes you have to lift a lot of weight.
But just because you ha- just because you can doesn't mean you need to be lifting, doing your PR every single time, right? Sometimes you gotta wi- lift a little bit little, or maybe you help someone- ... lift something, or whatever, right? You're training someone and you're going down on weight, you're scaling, right?
Or you're injured. Like strength comes with a level of like flexibility in it. But the- Yeah ... capacity is what we're, is what we're trying to build here,
Dr. John Schinnerer: let's go back to... And I like the idea of, I agree with the idea of capacity.
Humility and Asking Help
Dr. John Schinnerer: Let's go back to the idea of humility, 'cause I'm a big fan of humility.
Yeah. And I think a lot of men lack humility. Yeah. W- how would you define humility, and what does it give you?
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. So there's there's a spiritual definition and a [00:40:00] practical definition I go to. Spiritual def- definition, which we hear a lot, is like humility is the ability to surrender. And for a lot of guys, to the point you made earlier, that feels like weakness.
That feels like losing. That feels like failure, right? So I like that one, but I think for most guys, they're not ready to hear that, right? So the definition I'd actually use is humility is acknowledging your place in a hierarchy without judgment. So again, back to our physical metaphors. If you're new to a gym you're acknowledging "Hey, I'm not that good at this.
I'm out of shape. I don't know the movements, but I'm not going to judge myself. I'm not going to lash out at other people. I'm going to know my place. I'm gonna accept it with humility." And know that if I- if you can do that, you're gonna advance up faster than somebody who can't, right? So similarly, if you have a, a mental illness or you are struggling with trauma or you have whatever it's that surrendering which, again, feels like losing to guys.
It's like acknowledging yeah, okay, I have some work to do here. Doesn't mean you're stuck there at all. But it's like honestly acknowledging where you're at, what [00:41:00] your capacity currently is, and in doing that, that is the surefire fastest way to actually increase your capacity. Yeah. But so many men spend so much of their energy posturing, pretending that they are further along in X, Y, and Z category than they actually are, and that's arrogance, right?
And not only does it make people pissed off at you because you're a dick, it also prevents you from actually growing because so much of your mental energy is fe- spent on the facade rather than on working where you're at, right? Yeah. And improving where you're at.
Dr. John Schinnerer: I like your definition of humility.
The one I use is just the awareness to know what you don't know-
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. Yeah ...
Dr. John Schinnerer: and the willingness to ask for support.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Great. And because I've just seen... I, and I saw it myself years ago someone would try and tell me something, right? And I'd be like... and I didn't wanna let on that I didn't know, 'cause I, at that point in time it was really important to me to be seen as smart.
And so my, this like automatic unconscious response was just like, I know." And it's just dude, what are you doing? Have the humility to just listen and [00:42:00] consider maybe you know it, maybe you don't. And if it- have the confidence to just listen.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. A- and I think that takes some level of self-confidence, like you said, to be like, "Yeah, I don't know that." And it doesn't mean that you're stupid. Yeah. It just means okay, maybe you didn't study botany or whatever
Dr. John Schinnerer: the thing is about. Yeah. That's the key. It doesn't mean that you're stupid.
'Cause I think our insecurity comes up and... my biggest insecurity growing up was I'm not smart enough.
It was around intelligence.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: I think the thought that went through my head, the automatic negative thought specifically, was I'm a fucking dumbass.
And that shit came up after I had a PhD from Cal, which is amazing.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: No, I... and then I had to get to CBT and cognitive behavioral therapy and kinda challenge the thought and write down opposing arguments, all that kind of tedious work, but it helps.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. And that, that was the hole in your bucket, right? It's that- Yeah
dumbass thing. It's like it doesn't matter what you fill it with until you really confront that.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Marc Azoulay: All that- Well- ... energy and self-confidence you're generating.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. And I didn't realize how it's... I don't wanna say how significant it was, but it was... It really came to a head when I [00:43:00] became a student in the PhD program at Cal.
And I was just like, "Holy shit," "I don't know anything." Yeah. And then I was scared shitless. I was just like, I don't belong here."
I'm not smart enough.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. And
Enough Statements and Mentorship
Dr. John Schinnerer: then- And those enough statements really screw with us.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. Yeah. It
Dr. John Schinnerer: doesn't bother certain statements. I'm not strong enough, I'm not man enough, I'm not smart...
i'm not successful enough, whatever it is. Yeah. Those kill us.
Marc Azoulay: Th-th-they kill us, right? And I think again, if you find healthy men, which there are some out there, again, it's if you admit that to somebody that's a healthy man, they will love to help you.
Because I think- Yeah ... the way men show love, one of many ways, is through mentorship, teaching, learning, coaching. So again, if you're like, "Hey, I don't know the answer to this math problem," right? Or, "Hey I don't know how to do a power clean in the gym," or, "I don't know how to do this submission hold in Brazilian jujitsu," if there's a healthy man who's also confident, who's not trying to just, alpha you because he has his hole in his bucket- Yeah
he'll be like, "Hey, you know what? Thanks for telling me. Like, how about we spend some extra time and let's do some drills and let's figure this [00:44:00] out?" Yeah. And you can bond and make a connection with another healthy dude just by being humble. Yeah. It's very counterintuitive to what we think is gonna happen.
We think we're gonna get laughed and judged at and kicked out and abandoned, but more often than not, especially if you do a good job screening the men that are in your life, you get closer to them if you- Yeah ... express humility.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, and so l- let me just ask one other tangential question- Sure
before we wrap up.
Addiction as Masculine Strategy
Dr. John Schinnerer: I was curious about you have an idea of addiction as a masculine strategy. So tell us what you mean about that.
Marc Azoulay: Oh, for sure. Yeah, so I wrote a whole blog on that. Yeah. And basically it comes to that tough guy mentality of displaying masculinity, and you hear it in guys all the time, right?
I was working with a client the other day who's newly sober, and he's regretting his sobriety because he went to this golf tournament with a bunch of his friends, his brother and his brother's friends. And they were getting super hammered, and they were beating him at golf, right?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Oh,
Marc Azoulay: interesting.
They were better than him, and they were drinking and were- They were
Dr. John Schinnerer: better than him drunk. Okay.
Marc Azoulay: Yes, they were better than him drunk. Yeah. And he would say, and you hear this from guys all the time, he was like, they can [00:45:00] handle their liquor so well," right? Oh, yeah, they're able to do this stuff, and they were intoxicated, right?
You have these dudes that beat their chest and talk about how many beers they can drink without blacking out. Yeah. When I was going through my addiction stuff I'd n- never want to say no to hard drugs, like things like cocaine, because I didn't wanna look like a pussy, right? Yeah.
That's what I mean by masculine strategy is that it's a way to puff up your chest and try to climb that hierarchy. There's a hierarchy of, like, how much substances you can do and still remain conscious, right? You think of, again, these old tales of sailors drinking each other under the table.
It's so ingrained in Western culture- Yeah ... of a real man- has a addiction, right? A real man is a binge drinker or a binge smoker or a binge whatever-er,
Dr. John Schinnerer: yeah. And it's funny, 'cause I think of masculinity as being one of the hurdles we have to overcome in order to ask for help with an addiction.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: There- Yes ... and it's it brings up the idea of pride or the value of pride, right? Which I think is, has gotten a bad rap because I think it could be, you can have positive pride or negative pride. And, negative pride [00:46:00] is what makes you refuse help, makes you think you know everything, makes you only focus on achievement.
Positive pride is the emotional response you get when you've actually a- achieved something worthwhile or of value or benefiting others.
Marc Azoulay: Yes. Yeah. It's like with humility, right? 'Cause you, you have to admit that you can't- Yeah ... handle your drinks or whatever. And again, and I say that tongue in cheek 'cause I've been through my own recovery process, but for a lot of guys, that is really hard.
And I think for guys that are really down that rabbit hole, that pride in their ability to keep their shit together even though they often don't, if you look a little bit closer, that be- has become their identity. When it truly becomes- Yeah ... an addiction, it becomes an identity marker. It becomes who you are, what you're proud of, what you talk about, right?
I mean- Who you hang
Dr. John Schinnerer: out with ...
Marc Azoulay: who you hang out with, right? Yeah. Yeah. What social groups you're in. Like, how many alcoholics only talk about, beer, right? Or like- Yeah ... the, this whole connoisseur thing where it's like, okay, this guy knows a lot about whiskey. Maybe he's an alcoholic.
Like- ... you gotta drink a lot of whiskey to know a lot about whiskey,
Dr. John Schinnerer: so let me ask you one more thing. I just thought about this.
Fatherhood Lessons with Daughter
Dr. John Schinnerer: So you mentioned that you just became a new [00:47:00] father. Congratulations. Thank you. Seven-month-old daughter.
Marc Azoulay: Yes.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Now, It's, it- I've had two boys and two girls, and it's a vastly different experience parenting a boy than a girl.
What have you learned? I, I- it's only been a short amount of time, but what have you noticed has changed in you having a daughter or what you have learned or opened up to in that seven months?
Marc Azoulay: Yeah, I think for a father, I think daughters are in some ways easier because all we have to really do is just be the love of their life, and model our own healthy masculinity, which is a, a tall order, right? But you don't have to model it and teach it. You just have to model it, right? Because if you go back to, our buddy Sigmund Freud it's like she's gonna end up dating guys like you whether you like it or not.
Yeah. So your job as a father to a daughter is to be that, the man that you want her to eventually date, so right now as, as a little baby, most of it is just trying to beam as much love to her as possible, right? Being really vocal about, "I love you. Here's things I love about you.
Here's what I notice," right? Cuddling her, [00:48:00] being with all the intense emotions, right? And I'm starting to build that self-sacrificing muscle in a new way because, babies are tough, right? They, they- ... interrupt our sleep. They're gross. They, you know- Yes ... I have a physical boundaries thing, and there, she's always like in my personal space- Yes
right? Touching my eyes and nose, and in my mouth and stuff. And my, my job in those moments, and I'm learning it, moment by moment, is to just breathe and love her anyway, right? Love her- Yeah ... anyway. Let her explore and grow and do those things. So I think that's like my current edge is putting my needs aside, but not from people pleasing way, which is very different.
I'm used to putting my needs aside and then, being a nice guy. Yeah. But now it's put my needs aside and know that she's not gonna give me anything back. She's a baby. Yeah. She, she doesn't even know what's going on, but trying to really tap into that altruistic, paternal parenting experience of-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah
Marc Azoulay: hey you're here. All I have to do is love you, and all you have to, all you have to do is try to feel safe,
Dr. John Schinnerer: yeah. That's awesome. And one of the things that I loved was when my kids got to be about two-ish-
Marc Azoulay: Yeah ...
Dr. John Schinnerer: is they're really good teachers at teaching [00:49:00] you how to be present.
'Cause they're like, "Let's play Legos with me," or, "Play cars or play dollhouse," or whatever. And then you pick up your phone to look at a text and they're like Put the phone down. Like they're- Yeah ... they're- "What are you doing?" ... clawing your phone and putting it down like- Immediately
"No, you're with me right now. Pay attention to me now."
Marc Azoulay: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And and then, a little bit later you, you have to deal with your own protective instincts.
And then, ultimately letting them go and letting them be on their own at, 18-ish. And those are interesting experiences and lessons also.
Marc Azoulay: Yes. Yeah, I'm looking forward to that. I'm looking forward to the... I talked to my wife that I think parenthood is the most accessible, in some ways the most powerful spiritual path that I think we have as humans. By far, and it's, it's very accessible for most people.
I'm looking forward to those growths. Again, right now- Yeah ... as a little baby my job is just vibes, right? Just loving vibes. But I'm looking forward- Yeah ... to when I get to to your point parent more. Right now it's a lot of caretaking, which is-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah ...
Marc Azoulay: important, but when you get to parent, when it's about communication, when it's more about play, when it's more about setting rules or being tested.
I think it'll be really hard, and I think it will [00:50:00] make me a better man. There, there's no doubt- Yeah ... in my mind about that.
Wrap Up and Resources
Dr. John Schinnerer: Marc, thank you so much for the conversation. I greatly enjoyed it. Where can people get ahold of you and anything you have to offer?
Marc Azoulay: Oh, yeah. Sure. So all of our stuff is at menstherapy.online.
We have individual, we have couples, we have group. We do in-person experiences including a reunion and camping trips out here in Colorado. A lot of ways to work with us. But if you really wanna check us out, we have a lot of free content as well. So we have a podcast, which we're actually recording our episode on Friday.
Yes. So you'll, you'll- Looking
Dr. John Schinnerer: forward to that too ...
Marc Azoulay: talk to Dr. John. You can see his episode. We have, hundreds of blogs. We have a bunch of free quizzes and personality tests. There's so much content. We just added, we have filter, so you can filter based on whatever issue you- you're looking on.
But I would encourage you as check out that stuff 'cause I'll be honest, most people are not ready to take on the commitment of working with a therapist and a coach, but even just getting the information and starting to learn and starting to think about these ideas. If you've listened to this l- long in the podcast you already are in that category.
Yeah. Find some of the good information. And [00:51:00] we can find that stuff all at menstherapy.online.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Fantastic. Go check out menstherapy.online. It's a fantastic resource. And Marc, thank you for all the work you're doing. I really appreciate it.
Marc Azoulay: Yeah. Thank you. Thanks for having me on the show.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Absolutely. My pleasure. And that's it for this episode of The Evolved Caveman. Be sure to tune in. And oh, by the way, check out proximitycoaching.com for a free trial of your AI coach for either men, women, or couples. That's it for this show, and I'll see you next time.
