Episode 290 · 62 min
My Son Died From Fentanyl. My Guest Trafficked It. Ex-NFL Star - Shame, Redemption & the Courage to Heal
Can a man come back from his worst decisions?
Dr. John Schinnerer, whose son Brett died from a fentanyl overdose, sits down with former NFL player Jeff Hatch, who was arrested for trafficking fentanyl after a heroin addiction and relapse. Together they look at how a smart, successful man becomes someone he barely recognizes, and what accountability, honesty, and rebuilding trust actually require.
What this conversation covers
- Why success cannot cure shame. Ivy League graduate, third-round draft pick, millionaire at 22, and still running from himself.
- The power of secrets. Shame fuels secrecy, secrecy feeds addiction, and small compromises add up to a line he never imagined crossing.
- The Man Box and its costs. How football culture and male conditioning reward hiding pain.
- Accountability without self-destruction. Taking full responsibility for harm without deciding you are beyond repair.
- The Inner Kingdom. How protective instincts can wreck the life they were meant to protect.
Accountability and compassion together
Jeff never asks to be excused, and John does not need to condemn him to honor his son’s memory. What they find is understanding, accountability, and the recognition that people can change. Jeff’s measure of his life now: “I am not a ghost today.” Learn more about Jeff’s work and his book Unbuilt at unbuiltmethod.com.
Episode notes
What happens when a father who lost his son to fentanyl sits down with a former NFL player who got arrested for trafficking it?
Nearly three years ago, my son Brett died from a fentanyl overdose. My guest, former NFL player Jeff Hatch, was arrested after a heroin addiction led to trafficking fentanyl. Two very different experiences with the same devastating drug — and a chance to explore grief, responsibility, forgiveness, and redemption.
Jeff's story begins with extraordinary achievement: Ivy League graduate, third-round NFL draft pick, millionaire at 22. He had everything our culture tells men to want, yet was running away from himself.
When injuries ended his NFL career, addiction took hold. Even after finding recovery, he relapsed — and through small compromises and secrets, crossed a line he never imagined: trafficking fentanyl. His downfall cost him his career, reputation, relationships, and freedom.
But that's not where his story ends.
In this deeply personal conversation, we explore the distance between the man we show the world and the man we believe ourselves to be — how shame fuels secrecy, secrecy feeds addiction, and achievement becomes a prison.
We also explore what it actually takes to change — not the Instagram version, but the messy work of responsibility, honesty, self-compassion, rebuilding trust, and living by your values.
In this episode:
-
Why success can't cure shame -
The dangerous power of secrets -
The Man Box and its hidden costs -
Accountability without self-destruction -
The Inner Kingdom: how protective instincts can destroy the lives they're meant to protect
Perhaps the most powerful part was discovering that healing doesn't require denying the harm we've experienced or caused. Jeff never asked me to excuse what he'd done, and I didn't need to condemn him to honor my son's memory. Instead, we found something more meaningful: understanding, compassion, accountability, and the recognition that people can change.
Jeff describes his life today with a simplicity that stayed with me: "I am not a ghost today." He measures his worth now by whether he is an honest husband, a present father, and a man living by his values.
And watch for a surprise appearance by my son Brett, who chimed in from the other side to say (more or less), "I approve of this. Keep moving forward, guys!"
This episode is for anyone who has struggled with shame, addiction, grief, or the belief that they must achieve more to be enough — and for anyone who loves someone with addiction, or wonders whether redemption is possible.
Connect with Jeff Hatch: his work, coaching, and book Unbuilt at unbuiltmethod.com. Instagram: @oldkidhatch.
You don't have to go to prison or lose everything to begin changing your life. Proxi He, from Dr. John Schinnerer, turns decades of experience in men's emotional intelligence into an AI-powered coach available 24/7. Try it FREE for 7 days — just $25/month after. https://proximitycoaching.com/he
You don't have to become a different man overnight — just start becoming a more authentic one today.
Episode transcript: Jeff Hatch on Shame, Redemption, and the Courage to Heal
Dr. John Schinnerer with Jeff Hatch · The Evolved Caveman. Transcript provided for reading, with speakers labeled, timestamps retained, and name spellings corrected.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Hey, everybody. This is Dr. John back with the latest episode of the Evolved Caveman podcast. And the question for today is: How does a smart, successful man who knows better progressively become someone he barely recognizes? And what does the path back to redemption look like? My guest today is Jeff Hatch, a University of Pennsylvania football star and 2002 third-round NFL draft pick whose career was derailed by injuries.
Opioids became part of his addiction story. After years in recovery, he was publicly working in addiction treatment as sort of a celebrity addiction specialist while secretly using again. In 2019, his guilty plea involving transporting 1,500 grams of fentanyl became public. As a result, he spent three years in prison.
More recently, he has spoken openly about the double life, the [00:01:00] cost of secrets, identity after football, and rebuilding after public disgrace. He's the author of Unbuilt, a certified high-performance and personal transformation coach, and his experience in addiction, recovery, and rebuilding informs his work helping high performers close the gap between how their lives look and how they actually feel.
Fentanyl Loss and Apprehension
Dr. John Schinnerer: Adding to the layers within this interview, my son Brett died almost three years ago to the day from a fentanyl overdose. I was apprehensive yet excited to talk with Jeff, as the conversation offered possible insight and healing for both of us. And isn't that what life is all about? Growth, evolution, and healing
While most of us haven't transported fentanyl across state lines, we can all understand I'm doing something I know isn't who I want to be, and I'm hiding it from [00:02:00] those I care about the most. Today, I get the chance to talk to Jeff Hatch, retired NFL player who ran into trouble with the law after smuggling fentanyl across state lines.
But the story I'm most interested in is one I see quite frequently. How does a man progressively betray his own values while convincing himself he's still basically living by them? And once the illusion collapses, how does he build a life based on rediscovered values and objective truths rather than image or status?
Jeff, welcome.
Jeff Hatch: Hi, John. Thanks for having me.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, and, and before we got on the air, I was just telling you that I was, I was a little apprehensive and excited about having this conversation, partly because of that layer of my son's death. And, and what I didn't realize when I set this interview up, it- the death was, was almost three years ago to the day.
It was October 19th.
Jeff Hatch: Oh, wow.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And, and so I'm like, "Man, I'm, I'm, like, I'm feeling kind of weird this morning. Like, what the hell's going on?" Like, I'm a little out of sorts and maybe a little bit [00:03:00] irritable. Like, I'm kind of sad and emotional. I was like, "Oh, maybe this interview's a little harder for me than I, I realized it was going to be."
Jeff Hatch: Yeah, and it's funny 'cause the reach-out from me to you had no... I had no knowledge of that at all. No. It was strictly based on the ide- ideological alignment of the work we do with men, but the-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Which we almost do the same work, we were talking about before also.
Jeff Hatch: Right. Right.
Owning Responsibility and Context
Jeff Hatch: But w- when we talked about that, um, in our initial call about your son, I thought about it.
I just said, "Wow, this is, like, a... You know, it's heavy. It's a lot." Um, and it's, it's, it's a, it's tough for me, I'm just being straight up with you here. It's tough for me in the sense that, like, if I was you, some layer of me deep inside would be like, "This guy is responsible in some way." Um, and so I want to, like, just shout that out and call it out and say, "I get it."
Um, I would feel the same way. And realistically, John, like, I probably am a little bit. [00:04:00] Now, I want to create the caveat that as a man who's now in long-term recovery and been sober for over nine years, I can look back and say, like, everything I was doing in that time was, was strictly sur- for, for survival, right?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: Um, I was low on this totem pole in this operation, um, and I was just supporting my habit with what I was doing. And I, I say that because I think sometimes people who will listen to this or don't know the world of substance use disorder and all that, they don't understand the chasm that exists between someone who is manufacturing, selling, distributing drugs to a population of addicted people and is not themselves addicted-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm
Jeff Hatch: versus someone who is really in survival mode and doing what they have to do to get by every day, um-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah ...
Jeff Hatch: to, to try to get through. And, and that's, that's where I was. And again, like, I don't say that to excuse behavior and I don't say that to, um, do anything but call out the fact that [00:05:00] that's real.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
And, and thank you for saying that. And a couple things there. I mean, it- to me, it's the difference between explanation and excuse, which is a big distinction I make, right? Oh. It... You're trying to explain your behavior, not excuse it, I believe- Right ... i- if I had to speak for you. Sorry about that. No. Um, but, uh, the other thing is, I, I don't blame you.
Mm. I, I mean, I, I think that, um, interestingly when, when the death first happened, um- I was, I was furious at, like, God and the universe and my son, um, because honestly, he knew better than to put shit in his body that he hadn't tested And so it wasn't so much a blame, uh, of other human beings.
Jeff Hatch: Mm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: It was a blame, blame on kind of just how...
Like, he, he always ha- he, he struggled with life. Like, he just fought life, and it was really frustrating for me in the sense that I couldn't get him to put effort [00:06:00] forth in any area of life.
Jeff Hatch: Mm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: For pretty much his whole li- you know, like I coached soccer pra- you know, soccer teams, right? And he'd be the first kid into water break and the last kid out, and he was the kid walking on the field, and he was, you know, didn't like sports, but he didn't like academics, but he didn't...
Like, he just, there wasn't really anything that he got into.
Jeff Hatch: Mm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And so as a result, he started hanging out with the wrong crowd really early and, you know, started early with, you know, weed and, and then that led to alcohol, and then that led to just, you know, kind of turning his back on school. And then he's, you know, 18, 19, 20, and what do you do when you haven't put forth effort in your own life?
Yeah. And he turned to drugs.
Jeff Hatch: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And I, I mean, I remember it w- and it was really embarrassing for me too. Like, it, it was not the family I grew up in, it was not me as a kid. And I was just like... I, I remember having to work hard when he was like 13, 14, 15, because here I am, a professional in [00:07:00] the community, trying to work with young men, and my son is off the rails.
Oh, sure. And, you know, he was, he's Oppositional Defiant Disorder- Mm-hmm ... and he's ADHD, and then you throw the substance use on top of that. But I remember just having to divorce him from myself in my mind, like make a psychological separation of this is his life. These are his choices. And granted, I can do what I can around the edges, but if he's determined to do this stuff, that's his path.
He's gonna have to figure this out.
Jeff Hatch: Wow. That's gotta be- And
Dr. John Schinnerer: it, it
Jeff Hatch: was tough ... such a hard place to get. Um, and I appreciate you calling out that layer of it where it's like, "Hey, I'm a professional in this community. This is what I do, and my son is not a representation necessarily of-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah ...
Jeff Hatch: me and that work."
Um, that's gotta be a hard distinction to make too and kind of like hold that line there.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. It was rough, 'cause I think most people if they look at that situation are like, "That's your fault."
Jeff Hatch: Right.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And, and I knew at some level it wasn't my fault, because my ex-wife, her brother [00:08:00] had exactly the same problems growing up, and there's other people in her si- on her side of the family where you can see this genetic lineage of, oh, there it is again.
Oh, there it... It's about one in a four. Like, wow, what a trip. Right. And, and so I can't quite explain it, but you can see this, this genetic... I, I mean, there's a direct linkage.
Jeff Hatch: Right.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Right. Um, so, so anyway, um, so thank you for going through that with me. I appreciate it.
Football and the Man Box
Dr. John Schinnerer: So let me, let me just start off asking you, you know, what did football teach you about being a man that served you, and what did it teach you that- almost killed you.
Jeff Hatch: Oh. '
Dr. John Schinnerer: Cause that, that's all about the man box, right?
Jeff Hatch: It 100% is.
Dr. John Schinnerer: I mean, there- And there's some good and there's some bad in there ...
Jeff Hatch: that's exactly right. I think there is some good and some bad. I think for me initially, um, you know, I was always a big kid, and the way that manifested in my early aughts was that I would got made...
I was ostracized and made fun of a lot. You know, I was not a tough [00:09:00] kid growing up, so- Yeah ... um, I was an oaf and an ogre and, you know, that kind of stuff. And, um- I remember, I didn't start playing football till I was a junior in high school. I was a basketball player.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Wow.
Jeff Hatch: Yeah, so and I actually transferred to a school to play basketball there, and the football coach spotted me and was like, "You know, what are you, a new teacher at the school?"
'Cause I was like- ... 16 and I was already like 6'5" and like 250 and had a goatee. Wow. You know what I mean? He was like, "What?" I was like, "No, I just..." He said, "You gotta play." Anyway, so but I remember one of the positives always for me in football was right from the start it enabled me to have an environment where I could, um, be celebrated for expressing the aggressive side of my manliness, um, authentically.
Yeah. And that's by being physically violent with another human being. Um, and, and I got to take out all this rage I had built up through my y- youth of like no one likes me, I'm worse than, I'm an... Of all this stuff, it just erupted in that form on, [00:10:00] on, in that, in that sandbox. And it felt really good, um, to be able to get it out and be celebrated for it, you know?
Mm-hmm. So that was a positive. And that's, you know, neither here nor there in the grand scheme of things. I think if you want to talk kind of more of a canned answer about like what does football do, it creates discipline, it creates a level of respect for, you know, teamwork and all that stuff that, that is real, right?
That has served me in my life beyond football for sure. But I would say what it also did is create in me, um, a real difficulty in keeping things sorted in my mind between when I was at practice and playing and being that violent person, and then stepping away into my regular life and that being no part of any piece of what that existence is.
Hmm. And how do you flip that switch from, from on to off effectively? And for me, it was like definitely, um, [00:11:00] another means by which drugs and alcohol came into play. You know, it, it was another way for me to utilize that tool to create distance between myself and reality. Which is really all I'm doing. If I, if I've got substance use disorder and I'm using substances to the level that it becomes, um, that much of a problem, I'm not doing it because I'm enjoying it or because it feels good.
I'm doing it because it's a necessary tool for me to create distance between reality and myself. And so I was using it for that, for sure, even then.
Belonging Shame and Self Worth
Dr. John Schinnerer: What were you distancing yourself from? 'Cause I, to me, I'm always looking at what are the emotions driving the behavior and- Mm-hmm ... especially in substance use, I can always find a panoply of emotions that- are leading to triggers or impulses to use.
Jeff Hatch: Right.
Dr. John Schinnerer: So w- what was... Is that, is that accurate for your experience in the past?
Jeff Hatch: Absolutely. Right from the start, too. I mean, from the first time I drank alcohol at 13, it was... And I, I don't know why this is. I hear it very commonly in the rooms of recovery that I'm a part of, that when someone will share their story, oftentimes it leads with, [00:12:00] "Growing up, I felt like I didn't fit in and I didn't belong."
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: Now, I think that's a common trope for probably all of us in some way, shape, or form. Yeah, the
Dr. John Schinnerer: majority, for sure.
Jeff Hatch: You know? Um, but I think for, uh, for, for people like me, like, the solution to that feeling of lack of belonging was to mute all feelings. It was not to, like, build coping skills, build community in the appropriate way, anything like that.
It was like, let me run away from this as, as, as much as I possibly can. And so that was always there. Even, I will tell you, I remember thinking that there was gonna come a time where I would third dimensionally achieve enough success, you know, power, money, respect, that I would no longer feel this, that way about myself.
I would no longer hate myself, you know? I would no longer think I was worse than any of that stuff. Somehow I'm gonna get enough stuff and things to change that feeling, which again, all the messaging we get is saying that.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: It's all- That's, that's how we're
Dr. John Schinnerer: taught ...
Jeff Hatch: right. That's how we're
Dr. John Schinnerer: socialized.
Jeff Hatch: That's it. That's it. And [00:13:00] so I did that. I remember I was 22 years old. I came home from practice one day, and I sat down, and I looked at my checklist. I had graduated from an Ivy League school with a political science, philosophy, and economics degree. I had won the President's Award for Community Service.
I had been a third-round draft pick of the New York Giants. I signed my million-dollar contract, bought my house, was, you know, dating the pretty girl. Um, and I still hated myself.
Dr. John Schinnerer: I, I was gonna say, did, you know, did you feel enough-ness when you got drafted into the NFL? Absolutely not. Because it, it doesn't change like that, right?
It just doesn't- It doesn't do it ... it's like flipping a, flipping a switch.
Jeff Hatch: Right.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And, and that's, that's... 'Cause to me, it's, it's two of the things that are at the heart of this is, you know, shame and then self-worth, and, and they're kind of at opposite ends of the spectrum. And I, I've really gotten into shame a lot lately, um, partly because I discovered some in myself three, four years ago.
Okay. And I was like, "Holy shit, I've got shame in me." And, and my shame would come up in disagreements with Joree, my wife, well, now my wife, and [00:14:00] it, it really originated from this, like, I've hurt her, I've disappointed her, I've let her down- And I gotta tell you, I fucking hate to disappoint my wife. Like, it's- Mm-hmm
the worst person in the world. And, and so once I realized, oh my God, like I'm going... Like, I'd get flooded after 15 minutes of a disagreement, and I would just shut it down. I would just be like, "I, I don't want to say anything in anger. I'm getting triggered," right? Which is a great rationalization from the inside, but from the outside it looks like, and is, stonewalling.
Right. And, you know, I'm just like, "I'm not gonna talk to you anymore," and she feels abandoned. And when I realized it was stonewalling, and then I realized there was shame underneath it, I was like, "Oh, wow, like that's my shit. That's my issue."
Jeff Hatch: Mm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Like, I have to find a way to deal with that. And, and the first step was figuring or believing, choosing to believe I could.
Sure. Because that's existed for 50 years.
Jeff Hatch: Yeah, and I wonder where that started for you.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Oh, I think it goes way back to four, five, six. Okay. I think for most of us [00:15:00] it does. Yeah. It goes back to, you know, like finger-wagging from a parent. And I don't- Right ... I don't think our parents intend to instill us with shame, but I think it was a common parenting tactic back when...
I mean, I was... That was late '60s, early '70s.
Jeff Hatch: Sure. Sure. Same for me, right? I mean, I was born in '79, but the same thing.
Dr. John Schinnerer: I mean, so do you... Like, are you any more familiar with shame or, or sel- like, the, the flip of it, self-worth, in that journey?
Public Disgrace and Identity Masks
Jeff Hatch: I think I discovered that, um, and became, um... I sat in the shadows with my shame for a long time.
I'm sure. You know, because, 'cause after I relapsed and, and, you know, it... The interesting timeline is I, you know, I had relapsed, I got arrested, I got sober again, but it didn't become public until two years later. So the internal shame had been there for two years, then came the external forces piling on, which that piling on looks like fired from my job.
Everyone in my life says, "We don't want to [00:16:00] talk to you. We don't want anything- Yeah ... to do with you." I get the Facebook messages telling me I should kill myself. Oh. All that stuff starts coming, you know? And, and look, I mean, thank God that timeline went the way it did because I think if that had all hit at once, that internal shame as well as this external, um, I don't know if I would've been able to make it through it.
But with that distance and time, when that external came and I was left to sit with myself, it was almost like my spirit was prepared to, to go further into it. Because what I realized was every iteration of my life prior to that, no matter what had happened, I had very quickly been able to pick up a new mask, put it on, and perform that identity.
And this was the first time where there was nowhere for me to go perform.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: No one wanted me around. Um, and I was really then forced to shi- s- sit with like, why do I feel this shame? Why do I continue to try to externally manufacture- [00:17:00] a, uh, almost like a, I don't know, a caricature of what I think I should be inside, right?
Mm-hmm. I'm, I'm almost trying to fit my life to the, some broken image on the interior. And that was when I really sat with, oh, wait, dude, you need to, like, strip this whole thing down to the foundation and, and really get okay with, like, what are you beneath all of this? Um, so that's where it happened for me.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, and, and thank you for the answer. I, I mean, one of the things that I, I see with, with men a lot is we either go to I'm a piece of shit, like shame... And, and shame to me, just for definitions, is, I like Brene Brown's definition of, uh, it's a belief that we are unworthy of love, connection, or belonging.
But we either go to I'm a piece of shit, or it's all your fault, and we just externalize blame onto everybody else, anyone who's around. And, like, did you struggle with those two aspects? I mean, you, you kind of talked about the [00:18:00] shame, but I'm curious about how on God's earth did you get from it's everyone else's fault to oh my God, I got to own this, I got to take responsibility for this?
Jeff Hatch: Really good question.
Injury Secrets and Addiction Spiral
Jeff Hatch: Um, well, I will tell you, immediately as you were bringing that up, I thought about... So I had a, um, I had my first back surgery my rookie year, and really that was when opiates came into play for me, painkillers came into it. Um-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Was it, what was the back surgery? Like, what was-
Jeff Hatch: Um, I, I herniated a disc
Dr. John Schinnerer: out of curiosity. Okay ...
Jeff Hatch: um, and, and just to pull that apart a little bit, 'cause I think this is a common experience we all have, but I, I actually did that while I was training for the draft, and my agent was basically like, "Look, we have two options right now. We either, we get this fixed and you don't get drafted, and we try to get you signed as a free agent next year, or we figure out a way to make it through and get you [00:19:00] drafted as high as we can get you drafted.
And then when it becomes unbearable, you disclose and then now you're part of that team and they pay for the sur-," right? Yeah. So, so, so I was walking with this lie.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Anoth- yeah, another secret.
Jeff Hatch: A layer of fraudulence that I had n- at that time I was 22. I hadn't, I hadn't had to carry something like that before.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And something which you, over which you have no control. That's just your body.
Jeff Hatch: I know, which, which was really... That piece to me was the thing that took me the longest to get okay with, was the fact that I did not have control over that and I could not control it. Yeah. 'Cause I think that's a thing we, we really get to with men, with anyone in particular.
With, like, it's just this idea that we have more control than we actually do, and as a result of that, we beat ourselves up more than really we should. Um-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Well, and I think it speaks to our masculinity too, or, I mean, wrongly so. But I- Right ... I mean, I see it now, I'm almost 60 and, and I, I talk to a lot of men who are aging, and it's the same m- same idea, right?
It's like I, I... Sorry, that's my son Brett.
Mm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Thank you, Brett [00:20:00] He likes to turn the lights on and off in here. Um, at least that's my interpretation. Um, and, um, okay, so aging men, um, I, I mean, like, you know, I can't get hard. Um, I can't, I can't walk the steps. I can't swing a hammer. Like, there's all these things as we get older, and it create- that creates embarrassment in, in us, if not shame.
And I can't imagine at 21 when you're like, "My body's supposed to work perfectly," although you're playing football.
Jeff Hatch: Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah, that was really hard.
Acceptance Process Over Outcome
Jeff Hatch: And, and again, like, let me... I wanna finish that though, because what happened for me was I, I ended up playing for four years. My fourth year I was in Tampa playing for the Bucs.
Um, Gruden was still coaching, and I had a spinal fusion, and my career ended. Um, and I ended up in treatment two months later for, for drug and alcohol addiction, because I was... Once that career was gone and this justification I had built around I'm doing whatever I need to do to be on the field to play the game I love, [00:21:00] um, once that was gone, the recognition was, "Oh, I'm just a guy who's got a real serious problem at this point."
Went to treatment, and I remember I was, I was in treatment, and they... In the r- recovery process that I participate in, um, there is a prayer, and it, it talks about acceptance. And I was forced in this room of 90 other clients to sit in front of everyone and start reading this acceptance prayer.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And- Is this the sere- serenity prayer, or is this a
Jeff Hatch: different one?
It's different. No, it's- Okay ... it's, it's different, but it, it really just talks about, um, you know, I c- the only thing I can do is accept that this is the reality of what's happening and what is. Yeah. Um, and if I'm un- incapable of that, I, I have no path forward that isn't broken and jagged and built on sand.
Um, and I got about two lines into that and just started bawling in front of this room of, like, 90 people I didn't know, um, half of which were women, and, you know, [00:22:00] everyone there is like, thinks, you know, here's this Adonis football player who walked in here, and here he is now, like, snotty-faced, crying in front of everyone.
But it just-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Another blow to the masculinity, perhaps.
Jeff Hatch: Right. Right. But it, it hit me in a, in a layer that I had not been hit before, and I think that was the beginning of a very long, drawn-out process of getting to that place of understanding that, like, um- My masculinity, my manliness, who I am, my strength is not tied to the control of the outcome.
It's tied to the process by which I, I walk through that lack of control really, right?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: How much fortitude and resilience do I have to stand on my own two feet and be okay with the moment? That's a real man. But
Dr. John Schinnerer: like- And I, can I just pause you there and put a pin in that? Yeah. Because I, I think it's a really important point of focusing on effort over outcome is kind of what you're saying, right?
That it, it's a focus on the day-to-day process, the little steps [00:23:00] versus getting the A or getting, you know, drafted into the NFL- Yes ... or making a million dollars a year, whatever it is. It's all we can control is the effort that we put into it and those small steps. And, and you know, I love the question of like what's the next smallest step I can take in the right direction based on values, right?
Jeff Hatch: Yes.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Um, and so yeah, I'm, I'm 100% on board.
Jeff Hatch: I think that's a great, that's a... I, I say that all the time with my coaching clients. We are process-oriented, we are not outcome-oriented. If you're coming into this looking to, you know, uh, magically transform into the man you want to be, that, that's not what this is.
This is about building a process, building a daily disciplines that like you're willing to do every day to, in the long run, become the version of yourself that you want to become.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. And, and it's a hard one.
Rebuilding Trust Through Honesty
Dr. John Schinnerer: Like it, uh, this example comes to mind where I've walked several clients through like someone who's cheated on their wife, right?
And they're like, "How do I rebuild trust?" Oh. And I'm like, "Well, first it's gonna take a [00:24:00] while. Second, that timeline is not up to you. It's out of your control. It's up to her. And third, it's these little tiny steps that you make every single day or every moment of every day to show that you are trustworthy."
Jeff Hatch: John, I like, I wish I could express my, uh, my internal excitement that you brought that to, to topic right now because I'm- I didn't cheat on her, but a year and a half into my relationship with my wife, I did walk home one day and sit her down on the couch and say, "Hey, I'm getting charged with a federal felony for drug trafficking t- today, and you didn't know anything about this.
And I haven't been sober for 13 years. I've been sober for two years, and this all happened before you and I ever met and fell in love." But- Yeah. So
Dr. John Schinnerer: similar betrayal. It's a betrayal.
Jeff Hatch: It's 100%- Yeah ... a betrayal. And I just finished my second book, um, and it's really about that rebuild, about... It's about our love story and about how, like you just talked about, the rebuilding of that trust isn't happening [00:25:00] in some grand gesture.
It's happening in the day-to-day ongoing honesty, transparency, doing the things I say I'm gonna do, being where I say I'm gonna be when I'm gonna be there, bringing things to the forefront that maybe I don't want to bring up, that I don't love about myself, that need to be discussed on an ongoing basis.
All these things, right? These are the, the micro pieces of building trust.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. Okay, wait. Let me, let me pause you there for a second because one of the things that I work with men a lot, and I've struggled with, and I imagine you struggled with at some point, is how did you get more comfortable in those uncomfortable conversations where you have to bring up something like, "Ah, shit, I really don't want to bring this up," or, "This is embarrassing," or, "This doesn't feel good"?
Jeff Hatch: I think it's just experience of the outcome of having those conversations. I, I look at every aspect of myself, be it spiritual, mental, emotional, or physical, as a training ground.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: And the only way I'm able to build up the fortitude or resilience to continue to engage in a behavior is if I have built up experience that shows me that it, it [00:26:00] is the right thing.
And so I think for me, right, y- initially, it's, it's incredibly hard. It's, it's throwing the dust across the bridge in Indiana Jones and taking the step onto an unknown path, right?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Jeff Hatch: But then as you do it more, you start to build up this cachet of evidence that shows like, oh, in doing this, I am, at the end of this, gonna feel better about the situation.
And not only am I gonna feel better, but we're gonna feel better. We're gonna be- Mm-hmm. You do that enough times, you start... It, it becomes easier as time passes. At least that's my experience with it.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. I, I... And it's, it's hard. And, and I think it's something that we men are socialized to avoid. Like, we're not socialized in the direction of relationality, communication, and connection.
Like, when we're- Totally. And, and, you know, it's a huge generalization, but I think it, it holds true for the most part. And- I- I, I mean, one of the biggest complaints I hear from wives about their husbands is, "I can't connect with my husband." Yeah. To which my response is, "Mm, yeah, no shit." Like, I get that.
That's... We are socialized to be stoic and self-reliant and tough and [00:27:00] not to need anyone. And, and like, and all these things get in the way of us figure... Like, we don't even know how we feel a lot of times.
Jeff Hatch: Oh, my God, it's so real. Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: That's a- I mean, I, I... We... Normally, we've got like three emotions we can access, happy, sad, mad
Jeff Hatch: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: How did you, like, and so you must be well beyond that. How did you start to become more self-aware?
Learning Emotional Skills Over Time
Jeff Hatch: Well, I have to say that I would, I would tell you that I have always... I have to be honest and say I've always kind of leaned towards that, right? Okay, uh, and this is an example of that. In seventh grade, I remember it was the first time I ever felt depression.
Um, and I remember it. I mean, it was a physical weight I felt on myself that was, like, new, different, and I didn't like it.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Jeff Hatch: And my answer to that was to write poetry.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Cool.
Jeff Hatch: Um, so you know, I've always been a guy who leans a little more towards the, the genuine [00:28:00] expression of what's going on inside. Now, the worlds that I lived in and operated in were completely counter to that.
And so I had a lot of retraining around, like, "Oh, no, no, no, no, no, no. We don't talk about that. We don't do that. We don't say that. You are, you are the alpha of the alpha." You know? Yeah. Um, so we don't... So, so you know, it was... I- it's been a kind of like a winding up and then an unwinding of that for me. But like, again, I, I think it's just a long process of, of learning that it's okay to express these things.
And you have to walk... Y- your kid, you don't run. Like, you know, they're not sprinting at world record speeds right off the gate, right? They're getting up, they're falling down, they're crawling, they're stumbling, they're... I'm, I'm going through it with my daughter right now. She's, she's walking, but she walks like a little drunk Ewok, you know?
And like, as time goes, that will straighten out, but it's the same thing- Yeah ... with us and expressing any piece of ourselves, and we have to get okay with that process, right? That's the thing I think is the biggest problem, [00:29:00] is we are afraid to fail on an ongoing basis. Um, and as a result of that, we don't try.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. And you know, along... You know, your, the drunk Ewok comment made me think of a little bit of a tangent. Like, uh, I think you're right. I think we give up too easily when we're trying to learn new skills or take new pathways, and it pisses me off because, like, I think about... Like, I think about your daughter, right?
So when did she learn to walk? How many months was she?
Jeff Hatch: She was about a year when she started standing
Dr. John Schinnerer: up and taking- Okay. So at a year, and you've just watched this, so you're right in the middle of it. You can watch your one-year-old-ish be like... Like, it's not even, there's no doubt, there's no give up.
It's just, "I'm gonna learn how to walk like them." And we fall down over and over and over. We fall on our face. We fall on our ass. Like, I remember watching my, my oldest daughter. She had learned to walk, but she... I watched her back up to the bottom stair, and she gets her butt close to the stair, and she turns [00:30:00] around, and she looks, and she's like, "Okay.
The stair's right there behind me," and then sits down on the stair. And I was like, oh, my God. Like, we have to learn that that thing is still gonna be there when we're not looking at it, and trust to sit down on it. Oof. And so, uh, it, it always amazes me is, you know, I'm trying to tell people, like, look, you gotta, you gotta practice this skill.
You gotta do it- repeatedly, daily, five days a week, maybe three or four months, then it becomes part of your automatic unconscious habitual you. But short of that, you're just giving up. And by the way, all these skills are gonna feel uncomfortable and unnatural at first, but so did riding a bike-
Jeff Hatch: That's right
Dr. John Schinnerer: when we first learned it.
Jeff Hatch: So- That's right ...
Dr. John Schinnerer: don't freaking give up.
Jeff Hatch: That's right.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Keep going- That's right ... in the right direction.
Jeff Hatch: Totally. Totally. I think... And I think the messaging, oftentimes I think the messenger, people like us, right, um, we come to that conversation with that man and he, he hears what we say, and he goes, "That [00:31:00] is so far from where I am in terms of, like, capacity to be aware of and actually articulate the way I feel about myself, that I'm not even gonna try to walk down that path," right?
Mm-hmm. So it's almost like I tried almost, I'm not gonna say dumb it down, but, like, ease the level with a guy on the front end to be like, "Look, man, y- y- don't try to get... Don't try to be Michael Jordan the first day you're out here." Yeah. But it's harder in personal development, I don't know if you feel this, I feel this, I see this all the time in coaching, is that it's harder for people to understand the long game of the process of this internal development, right?
We have this idea that this switch turns on and we are self-actualized. And, and, and it's way easier 'cause we see a lot more example. We hear the story of Michael Jordan getting cut from his basketball team as a sophomore in high school, and how much work and effort he put into getting there. When people...
We don't see the Dalai Lama and hear that, you know, he fought against his, his internal struggles for decades before he became- Mm-hmm ... this person who could ex- express peace and gratitude and joy on a daily [00:32:00] basis, right? So I think that's important to articulate as well.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, how, how much work did it take him to forgive the Chinese that came in and raided his people and killed a, you know, a lot of his people?
Um- Yeah ... and then took his land and kicked him out of his country. Um, and that's why, you know, this, this- this conversation that we're having, I was excited about it at one level, because I think it does offer the possibility of growth, evolution, even forgiveness. Like, I... And, you know, it's just interesting, as we're going along, I feel much better.
So it's interesting how that works, too. Yeah.
Relapse Begins With Secrecy
Dr. John Schinnerer: Um, so let me, let me ask you this, and I, I think I know the answer to this one. But was there one... 'Cause this is kind of the opposite of, uh, you know, coming out of the depths. This is going into the depths. Was there ever one giant decision where you crossed the line, or was it 50 tiny decisions, each of one- each of which could be, like, easily rationalized or explained to yourself at the time?
Jeff Hatch: Yeah, and I'm gonna frame this around, uh, around the [00:33:00] relapse, right? Because I think initially, the first time I got sober and started making those decisions, um, I really had no idea. I didn't know better. Um, but I did know- Mm ... better the second time around.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Ah.
Jeff Hatch: Um, and I always describe it as, like, I'm, I'm building a wall, um, between myself and you, right?
And you being the representation of the universe, God, as I understand him, community, love, joy, comm- all that stuff that is 100% based around my connection to other human beings and the world. Uh, and the hardest brick to put down is the first one. And so for me, that story that I have to create to justify that initial behavior is the hardest one for me to believe.
Um, but once I do that- It becomes a lot easier to see the structure of that wall and put another brick on top and put another brick on top. And so for me, what happened was I woke up from this surgery, I had a total knee replacement, and I [00:34:00] clicked the button and, um, I got that flood of that, that pain medicine in my system.
And here's the thing, it wasn't that I got the flood of pain medicine. That's okay. That feeling has... I mean, I'm a guy who that feeling will always be there if I experience that drug, whatever. The problem is I didn't say anything. I didn't tell anyone. I didn't call the guy who was my sponsor. I didn't tell my family.
I didn't tell any friends. I didn't say, "Hey, guys, this happened. This is the way I feel." I held it as a secret. And once I started building in that secret, that really was where... Then, then all of a sudden... I mean, and you gotta look at, look at my story, right? I mean, I go from there to trafficking fentanyl, right?
And that does not happen in, in, in a s- in a linear situation. It happens in, like you talked about, these micro allowances of worse and worse behavior. So it goes, I don't tell anyone about this situation. Then I get [00:35:00] a prescription for fentanyl patches because at this point now I've played in the NFL, I've done stunt work in movies and television, I have a spinal fusion, a total knee replacement, chronic pain.
No one understands what that's like. I'm taking this medication as it's being prescribed, so everything's okay. Okay, there's that one. Then it goes, boy, you know, I'm taking this medication as it's prescribed, but it would be so much easier, uh, just to get heroin. Now, I've never done heroin. And cheaper.
Small Steps to Arrest
Jeff Hatch: And cheaper.
And it'll do the same thing, so why don't I just do that? Okay, I do that. Well, then I'm spending all the money I'm earning at the drug dealer, and when he presents me an opportunity to go pick up his load and bring it back to him and then get my personal use amount for free- Well, that makes sense.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: And so it's these little steps, these little increments along the way where it just goes like, I'm allowing that. Well, then I get comfortable in that allowance. I'm allowing that. I get comfortable in that. And it ends up with [00:36:00] me, you know, getting arrested and being charged with a federal drug crime.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
And, I mean, it's interesting just in terms of... And, and it... One of the things that frustrates me about your story is it's a story I've heard several times before, starting in high school.
Jeff Hatch: Mm-hmm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: You know? And it, it's always, like, an athlete with an injury. And I remember I had a lacrosse player once, and he had a shoulder injury, and he was like, "Hey, anyone got anything, got any Advil?"
And someone, a teammate was just like, "No, I don't, but I got this. Here, try this." And it was like, I don't know, Vicodin ES. And that started him off, and then, I don't know, maybe two years later he was shooting up heroin between his toes before high school.
Jeff Hatch: There you go.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Um, and yeah, that's... I- it's a rough road.
Shame and Secrecy Spiral
Dr. John Schinnerer: And- and so here's, here's another question. And I- I think this is a little bit obvious too. I'm- I'm throwing you softballs. Um-
Jeff Hatch: Sure ...
Dr. John Schinnerer: so what's more dangerous for men, the thing we're ashamed of or everything we do to make sure no one discovers it?
Jeff Hatch: You said that was a softball. [00:37:00] What are you talking about? That's not-
Dr. John Schinnerer: I thought I thought it was easy.
Jeff Hatch: Yeah. I think, I mean, w- I'm gonna lead it to source and say it's the initial thing that, that, that we are feeling the shame around that is the thing that we have to, um, you know, that's the harder thing to address, right?
'Cause that's more deeply ingrained than all the little decisions we make along the way to hide and escape and run away from whatever that is. But yeah, and um, I, I think that, that again, for me, was like whatever this power greater than us in the universe is, new for me, um, you need that, that thing to be, number one, broadcasted out to the world, and number two, you need to sit in a space where you have no escape from it, or otherwise you're gonna continue to create stories to- Yeah
not address it. So I'm... I look back, I'm grateful for it, you know what I mean? If you, you know, yeah. But, but that's my, that's my take.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, yeah.
Grateful for the Path
Dr. John Schinnerer: And I mean, that's the other question I had for you. Would you change anything now that you're here?
Jeff Hatch: Not at all. [00:38:00]
Dr. John Schinnerer: Not a thing. And isn't that weird?
Jeff Hatch: Oh my gosh. Right?
You know, I just- I,
Dr. John Schinnerer: I, I think it, it's absolutely the right answer, I just think it's really fucking weird.
Jeff Hatch: I'm so with you. I'm so with you. And I used to hate it. I would go in these meetings that I go into and, um, someone would say they were grateful for being a person. Going.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Jeff Hatch: And I would be like, "You mother..."
Like, don't you dare. Yeah. And here I sit with that, that exact take because, you know, I don't know, man, whatever it takes for us to get chiseled down to what we were intended to be at the beginning, um, is what it takes. And, and I say that- Yeah ... that's, that's... I wanna, I wanna just... This, that leads me to ask you a question, right?
Unlearning the Man Box
Jeff Hatch: I, I think a lotta times we confuse our work, or people confuse our work with some, um, we'll call it like a rebuild. And you know, I was very conscientious in the wording of the [00:39:00] title of my book to call it Unbuilt, and the idea that we have to like remove a lot of stuff before we can start building anything.
And I wonder if, does that show up for you in your work? I mean, do you see these guys where you have to really separate story to get to what is actually real first?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. I, I think... I mean, one of the ways I think about it, which is consistent with yours, is I think of it as an unlearning, right? We gotta unlearn all the shit that we've learned over the years.
And, and we needed, like all that man box stuff that we learned, and as I said before, there's some good and some bad in there, and I can, you know, go into detail on that, but it's- It's necessary for survival, right? Like, I needed- Yeah ... to play by those rules through elementary school, middle school, high school, um, to survive.
I, I wasn't a fan of them. I, I even knew at the time, 'cause I was like you, like, I had some depression in me, I had some anxiety. I was a geek in many ways, but I could also play, right? I did [00:40:00] three sports as a senior.
Jeff Hatch: Mm-hmm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: But I, I... So I knew how to walk in both worlds. My world, which I preferred, you know, kind of this individual, artistic, emotionally deep world, and then there was this other world that I had to find ways to survive in And, yeah, so where was I going with that?
I totally forgot
Jeff Hatch: Well, we were, we were talking about the idea of kind of separating, particularly, like, with our clients, and, and, and really I think you're right to take it to men in general, that we have created this kind of ideological framework we operate under that is taught to us, that we really have to unlearn a lot of that to become what we really
Dr. John Schinnerer: are.
Yeah.
Connection and Trust Crisis
Dr. John Schinnerer: And, and I think the other part of it is learning to take off the mask, learning to take off the armor, learning to undo our defensive strategies. Um, and, and really reprioritize some of the values because, uh, I, I mean, one of the things in positive psychology that I learned, I don't know, 20 years ago, which [00:41:00] kind of irked me, was that, you know, one of the pillars of a happy, thriving, fulfilling life is relationships and connection.
And I was like, "Like, not, what? Like, now I gotta go out there and be like, like, talk to people and be nice to people and connect with people?" And I'm only exaggerating that a little bit, 'cause I can be a little introverted.
Jeff Hatch: Right.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Um, but it's, it's true, right? And so I, I, I had to put connection towards the top of my list, and it slowly over time, little steps, you know, changed everything.
Like, I started trying to connect with people around me, strangers, like waiting in line. Like, can I, can I find a way to just connect with this person in a positive way in the next two to three minutes? Because if we do, if I do, we both walk away winners in that we get this small positive emotional drop in our bucket.
Now, you know, those are cumulative, so if you get 10 of those a day, and 70 a week, and X number per year, like, it's m- it changes how you view the world around you and [00:42:00] people around you at large. And one of the questions I ask clients is, "You know, what percentage of people as a whole would you say are trustworthy?"
Or fill in the blank, or good, or kind, or would help you if you needed help. And I, I just did a podcast in, on this on, like, the decline in trust in the US, but it's down to, like, a third of people will say, or, or we think, the most of us will think a third of people are good or trustworthy. And that's not a belief that can sustain democracy.
Jeff Hatch: My
Dr. John Schinnerer: gosh. Like, we gotta change that.
Jeff Hatch: Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: It's not a belief that will sustain community or neighborhoods. It's not a g- belief that will sustain relationship. Like, so we, we've gotta- try and cultivate these experiences with others that reinforce our belief in the goodness of human nature
Jeff Hatch: Oh, man. That is so good and so real.
And, and, and I agree with you 100%. And I, I can only speak for... You know, my experience with that has been, um, I, I, I hold myself to a, a relative, [00:43:00] I believe, a relatively high standard in terms of the daily disciplines I engage in to try to be my best self, right? And I've been on that path for a long, long time.
But for a very long time, the goal of that path that I saw was for me to feel good, and then Go from there. And the understanding that has come for me in the past decade, I've been building towards it and it just comes truer every day, is that, like, no, the, the purpose of all of that internal personal work is so that I can be useful and helpful.
Is so that I'm bringing that to the world and using it to create good. Um, and I think that's a little bit of where we're going and why this trust has declined, is that the idea of what is good or right has a little bit transformed to who has the most [00:44:00] money, power, and influence versus who's willing to go pull their neighbor's trash can in or...
We don't celebrate that. We don't celebrate the person who goes and volunteers at the YMCA every week. We don't celebrate the guy who does the reading program in the elementary schools. Yeah. We celebrate Elon Musk, right? Yeah. 'Cause he's going to Mars. And you know, it's like, well, wait. Wait, wait, wait, wait.
We all need to bring the framework back in a little bit and go, like, what's happening in our sphere of influence, in our world, right? And, and I just wanna say one other thing on that. That's this weird thing around social media, is I am immediately connected to the entire world through this digital device, but in no way, shape, or form is that digital connection the real genuine personal connection that comes from sharing space with another human being.
Yeah. And we do that less and less today, I think, which is part of why we don't trust each other.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Well, and I think social media also is this bullhorn for humans acting in a [00:45:00] terrible way a lot of times, right? Whether it's rage or attack or shame or embarrassment, it, it's, it's... Y- we, we overgeneralize from seeing one person do something shitty to all people are shitty.
And that's a- Right ... it's a cognitive error, and it's something I think we have to guard against and fight against.
Jeff Hatch: That's a really good call. I agree with you 100%. That is so
Dr. John Schinnerer: real.
Inner Kingdom and the Knight
Dr. John Schinnerer: Um, all right, so I, there's one question that I did write ahead of time, and so I'm gonna read it, but, um, this one was kind of interesting to me.
So I, I think we talked about this on our first conversation. Mm. But just to remind you, I'm playing around with this new inner kingdom model. I just finished a book on it. But I, I use this model to explain the voices in men's heads to them, and in our heads, I would say there's a wounded squire carrying old beliefs and pain.
That's the young part of you. There's a knight whose job is to protect the squire. There's the lover, who's just looking for connection and is more of our emotional side. And then there's the king, who has to decide who the man wants to be. [00:46:00] And so listening to your story, I was wondering whether the drugs became one hell of an effective knight- And that they protected you from the pain right up to the point until they started destroying the kingdom.
So when you look backward, what was your knight protecting you from? Was it more than just feelings of emptiness? And we, we've touched on this a little bit
Jeff Hatch: Yeah. Um Yeah, I think he, yeah, protected me from feelings of emptiness, from feeling not good enough, from, um, the pressure of trying to be perfect in every way.
Um, because that was a big piece of my story, right? I, I- Yeah,
Dr. John Schinnerer: perfectionism. Yeah ...
Jeff Hatch: Well, and my, you know, my dad retired on disability when I was 12. He was a computer scientist for NSA, but he hurt his back really bad and retired at, when he, when I was 12, and went on really h- went on morphine, and really kind of, like, [00:47:00] disappeared.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Wow.
Jeff Hatch: And I started basically serving as, like, the emotional surrogate in the relationship with my mom. And the idea of, like, bringing happiness into that house became my call, right? Um, and so I think that led me to trying to do everything perfect. Um, and the drugs definitely, once they came in, helped remove that, um, and well, the, my knight protected me from that.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Okay, so follow-up question, and I'll, I'll use a Oren phrasing here. This is the money shot. Um, how does it feel to have your king back on the throne again now? Like, what is, what are the feelings that you have? What's your self-worth like? Like, paint a little bit of a picture of the positive things going on in your life right now because, and, and I think the feelings are a really important piece of that, because I think it's hard to conceive of for someone who's on the other side wallowing in [00:48:00] shame right now.
King Back on Throne
Jeff Hatch: Yeah, and I just want to say, I mean, I'm a guy, John, who for an extended period of my life literally did not interact with other human beings outside of the person I was purchasing drugs from and the checkout clerk at Subway to buy the meatball sub that I ate every day as food. And I would wake up with urine-stained pants, um, and I was a ghost.
Um, and I am not a ghost today. And the way that feels is, um, first and foremost, I feel contentment. I think that is so important to say out loud because if you're reaching for waking up every day and feeling like you're, you're, you know, the king of the world, that, that's not what this is. But what it is is I wake up in the morning, and I am 100% okay with who I am.
That is a miraculous thing that I, I honor and [00:49:00] carry really tight. I'm also, I'm proud. I'm proud to sit here with you and say, "Man, I am proud of the husband I am." I'm proud of the father I am. I'm proud of the worker that I am. And the reason I'm proud of those things is not because I knock it out of the park every day and do it all right, it's because I do it honestly, vulnerably, and transparently.
You know? I am who I am, and I am 100% okay with that because I do strive to be better every day and do good and be useful. And so I think contentment is, number one, um, some genuine actual pride. Not grandiosity. Like, I really do. Like, the evidence is there to support that I am doing the things I say I do every day.
Um, and then what happens is I get this incredible gift from the universe where I feel moments of joy.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm.
Jeff Hatch: Moments of true joy that I am present enough and aware enough to experience. And, um- That [00:50:00] is just, like, the cherry on top
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. Uh, thank you for that.
Contentment and Healthy Pride
Dr. John Schinnerer: And, uh, 'cause I, it... One of the ways we know you can motivate yourself when, with goal-setting is to focus on the emotion that you're looking to feel once you hit the goal.
Jeff Hatch: Mm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: It- it's one of the... It's a really powerful way to do it. And, and I... It's funny you say contentment. One of my favorite emotions. And, and contentment I would describe as, if you think of a emotional spectrum from 1 to 10, with 1 being, like, really suicidal and depressed, 5 being neutral, and 10 being, like, excited, super happy, like, really extremely intense, positive emotions, contentment's about a 6.
It's, like, mildly happy. And, and I, the, the question I love with contentment is if, if you ask yourself right here right now, "Are all my basic needs met?" Like, well, yeah, I got a roof over my head, I got, uh, heat if I need it, I got clothes, I got food, I got a toilet down the hall, which is, you know, really [00:51:00] important to me as a German.
Um, and if you can answer that question yes, you're at least content. Now, you might be other things, 'cause we can feel more than one thing simultaneously. You might be stressed, you might be angry, you might be exhausted, might be proud. Any number of things, but you're also content. And it's, it's partly a matter of what do you focus on, what do you train your mind to focus on.
That's it. Um, the other thing you mentioned is pride, which fascinates me because I think... I don't know of another emotion which is simultaneously awful and a deadly sin and positive. Like, it is so diametrically opposed the directions we can go with pride. Like, what the fu- Like, who decided that one? I think we need two, two separate words.
Jeff Hatch: Come on. Please. Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Like, I, I don't know what... Like, arrogant pride and, you know, like, positive pride. I don't know. But pride, I think, is a, is a really underutilized emotion when you've got healthy pride.
Jeff Hatch: That's
Dr. John Schinnerer: right. And, and, you know, healthy pride, I would say, is pride [00:52:00] based on you doing the small steps that you need to in the right direction on a consistent basis to make yourself into who you wanna be, and you're acting in keeping with your values.
Um, you know, I, I think the, the arrogant pride is just fueling your, your mask or your ego or your wallet.
Jeff Hatch: Totally. Totally. And it's a moment. That's based on a moment. That's based on me hitting the game-winning shot- Right ... and then everybody celebrating me. What you're talking about, the healthy pride, is that one like we just talked about.
Like, it's built in through, I am proud of the person I am and who I'm representing in that regard every day in what I do, right? So I think those are two vastly different things and, yeah. I don't know. We need better words.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Kindness as Core Value
Dr. John Schinnerer: Let me, let me ask you this, 'cause this is... I, I mean, I've, uh, interviewed, I think, three world-class experts on this podcast about meaning and purpose.
So it's, it's, you know, values, it's- It's all the stuff that we never talk about, but it couldn't come more important. Like, it just, it doesn't get more important to me. What do you think is the single most important value for leading a happy and fulfilling life? [00:53:00] A life of which you're proud Could be wealth, could be money, could be fame, could be influence.
Those are all the shitty ones. I'm just giving you off the top of the
Jeff Hatch: Yeah. Uh, I, I mean, what, what, what just continues to fester to the top of this bubbling cauldron in my mind of what I'm thinking is kindness.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Kindness to...
Jeff Hatch: To the, to the, to, to the universe, John. Yeah. To ourselves, to our closest companions, to people at large, to, you know, the checkout person at the grocery store.
Um, I... And I really wanna shout out again to ourselves.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Jeff Hatch: Um, I think that you cannot effectively be kind to anything if you are not kind to yourself or work to represent it. And I bring that because it's really something I'm working on. Um-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah ...
Jeff Hatch: it, it's been brought to my attention, right? It's like, you know, I am, um...
I think because a long time in my [00:54:00] life my... I was very egocentric, and partly by, by, by necessity, right? I can't walk out on an NFL practice field to practice against Michael Strahan every day and not think that I'm really good at what I do.
Dr. John Schinnerer: For sure.
Jeff Hatch: You know? And that created this weird si- self-centered, egotistical, my mom would call it NFLitis piece of me.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm.
Jeff Hatch: Um, and so, like, peeling that apart and coming to this understanding of, like, um- I am, I am one among many, um, and that is 100% okay. I'm not perfect. I'm not the best. I'm not the worst. I never will be either of those things. Um, I am in the gray in the middle. And, like, getting okay with that enables me to then be a little bit kinder with myself when I don't show up the way I want to necessarily or always represent the ideals that I hope to in every single thing that I do.
That then builds this base layer where I'm much more capable of being kinder, and, and [00:55:00] this thought just came into my head, kinder to the person who cuts me off in traffic.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: Because I can immediately be self-centered in my thought that, "You asshole-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm ... you
Jeff Hatch: just got in my way." What if they're going to the emergency room?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Mm-hmm.
Jeff Hatch: What if their wife's in labor in the car? What if they just- Yeah ... you know what I mean? Like, I don't know. So that, that really, like, once I've built that into my own inner structure, then I'm much more capable of carrying it, and I don't think much more brains, um... You know, y- you often talk about loving kindness meditation, right?
Um, and it says, like, you know, one of the, the tags in there is, like, let me live with ease. And, like, for me to live with ease, l- leading with kindness, compassion, these kind of things, that, that, that enables me to be able to do that much more-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah ...
Jeff Hatch: um, presently.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah, I think it's a good answer. I, my, mine is serving others, which there's a kindness element to that.
And- For sure ... and I like your wrapping in of self-kindness because I think, you know, back to that, circling back to shame versus self-worth, I haven't found a [00:56:00] man that I've worked with in 30-plus years that has, that hasn't at some point struggled with self-worth.
Jeff Hatch: For sure.
Dr. John Schinnerer: In- including myself. And once I realized that, I was like, "Oh, shit, like, how do I increase my self-worth?"
And one of the ways I do that is by repeating loving kindness phrases to myself anywhere from, you know, three, four times a day to once every couple days. But it's like, you know, it, may I, may I be happy, may I be healthy, may I live life- Sure ... with ease and wellbeing. But then I'll go to- Right ... may I feel worthy, may I f- may I feel worthy of love, may I feel worthy of relationship or wealth or success or impact or whatever, you know, I want to throw in there.
It's odd to me that we grow up without those thoughts in our head. Like, I think we have to actively work to insert thoughts like that into our head because we've got to combat that negativity bias and the inner critic, which I also wanted to get back to you 'cause you were mentioned in that self-kindness piece that you're working on that.
And [00:57:00] I got to imagine as, you know, a star football player that your inner critic was kind of a dick.
Jeff Hatch: Oh, gosh. Such a dick. Um, yeah. And I mean, like- I'm trying to be more... Uh, uh, he was and, and still is. I mean, my, my inner critic is still really tough. But what I, what I try to do is, is to wrap in your answer to that about serving others.
Taking In the Good
Jeff Hatch: And so, so, like, I'm sure you, b- both of us, I, I get, I get the opportunity to go do, do talks. Not all the time, but somewhat often, and I enjoy it. And, um, you know, it's one of the places I think I actually have a, a decent skill set for, and I bring a uni- a unique message. And I just spoke to a group of union guys, right?
These union, uh, electricians, right? And this is a very alpha environment, similar to athletics. And-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yep ...
Jeff Hatch: I get in there as this 6'7", 275-pound dude who's pretty, you know, [00:58:00] relatively muscular and strong, and I'm talking about feelings and crying and sharing emotional stuff. Um, and they wanna come up afterwards and be like, "Thank you," like, "That was...
Wow," you know?
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah.
Jeff Hatch: And I still have a real hard time allowing that to land, uh, because I, I always go to the place that if that lands, I start to think I'm somebody. And the minute I start thinking I'm somebody, I start acting in ways that I am not proud of. So I try to- Huh ... I try to turn it back to them as quickly as possible, and, like, ask them their story.
"What's your, what's your... Who are you? Tell me about you." So I'm working on a, a cleaner landing pad for that stuff in myself.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yeah. And, and that, that's an interesting... Like, I, I, I was with you all the way up until the end, and then you put a, a twist in there where I was like, "Oh, huh." Like, I wonder if that can be true sometimes.
Because, like, one of the things I work on with a lot of men is this idea of taking in the good, and it's from Rick Hanson, uh, in the North Bay [00:59:00] here, who's a New York Times best-selling psychologist, neuropsychologist, something like that. And... But the idea is that the mind is like Teflon for the good and Velcro for the bad, partly 'cause of that negativity bias, that the bad stuff, you know, you get 10 compliments and one criticism, and you're gonna over-focus on the criticism, and it stays with you at 2:00 AM in the morning for three nights.
And the, one of the solutions to that is to consciously focus on taking in the good, to believe that other people can often see the positive in you far better or the impact that you're having far better than you can, and that people are being sincere and honest with us, and actually taking something of a risk when they're giving us a nice compliment.
And it, it is... And I remember Joree used to get mad at me about this. I don't know about mad, but annoyed. That, uh, she would give me a compliment, and I had this kind of stock response of, "Mm, thanks," because it made me uncomfortable, right? Which it always [01:00:00] has. And I, my mom was terrified of me becoming arrogant- So much so that she used to insult me as a kid.
We can, you know, discuss that in another conversation That's another
Jeff Hatch: episode,
Dr. John Schinnerer: for sure. Yep But, um, we'll unpack that later. But, um, you know, I- I think there is this fear about becoming arrogant, and it's, it's interesting to me what's the difference between arrogance and self-confidence. Because arrogance, I believe...
I don't think anyone can actually tell me I'm arrogant. I think only I can make that decision, because only I know. Arrogance is when I feel like I'm amazing or I'm doing great work or I'm smart or whatever it is, and I'm better than everyone else, or I'm better than others. There's a hierarchy, right? I'm up here, you're down there.
Self-confidence is I can be awesome in any area, and everyone else can be awesome, too. They, they might be different areas, and that's okay. We have different strengths and weaknesses, but I'm not putting myself up above others. That's- But [01:01:00] anyway, to get back to... Sorry. You make me think of a lot of different things at once.
Wow. But, um, the, going back to the taking in the good with Rick Hanson, the, the practice is to believe what they're saying is true, to practice opening up your heart and receiving the compliment. Visualize receiving it into your heart. It, it fills up your heart, and then spills out of your heart and into every cell in your body.
And, and all you do is sit with the compliment and choose to believe it is true for 10 to 15 seconds. And, and what are you doing when you do that? You're rewiring neural pathways to begin to believe that you have these positive traits.
Jeff Hatch: Right.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Right. And, and I think there's something really valuable to that, because I think that also ties into increasing your self-worth.
Jeff Hatch: Totally. And I, you know what you said in there that stung me, because I, I think that's real. And, and again, work in progress, right? I mean, way better than I used to be in that idea of letting, [01:02:00] allowing the space for that thing to land before I immediately jump to, "Let's think about you." Um, but you said the risk they're taking, um, in, in giving that, and I, I have not really spent time with that, uh, and I need to, because that's real.
You know, it's not easy to go up to someone you don't know, or maybe you even do know them, and give them a genuine compliment about something- Yeah ... they're doing. So I need to be more aware of that as a piece of the puzzle. Because, yeah, um, that's hard. You know, it's hard, not necessarily... It's hard for the simple fact that my inner critic is who he is.
Mm-hmm. But also hard because there's some strange piece in me that says- If I allow this to land, I will grow complacent to continuing to work as diligently as I do
Dr. John Schinnerer: See, I don't think that's true
Jeff Hatch: I, it's not true
Dr. John Schinnerer: And, and the research shows it's not true
Jeff Hatch: It's not true. It's not true. But you know what I mean?
That's the silly little-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Well, I, I think it's the inner critic, and to me, [01:03:00] the inner critic is the knight who's turned his sword inward at myself Mm-hmm Right? But it's the, the, the inner critic or the knight inside going, like, "Ah-ha-ha." He's kind of, you know, got the wax mustache, the handlebar mustache.
Yeah, yeah, yeah And he's like, uh, you know, he's like the cartoon villain in the, the silent movies. Yeah But he's like, "Oh, man, he doesn't really mean that. He's just blowing smoke up your ass. Ah, he's trying to get something out of you." You know? Yeah There's so many ways that we can dismiss a compliment, but the biggest one for me is it just made me embarrassed and uncomfortable.
I don't know why it embarrassed me. Right Like, I just, I... Little social anxiety, right? I was like, "I just want to get the fuck out of here."
Jeff Hatch: Right, right, right, right. Right? Right. Right. Right. No, that's so real, 'cause I simultaneously want, um, I want everyone to hear what I have to say, because I feel like it's useful and helpful and can carry, they can carry away something from it.
But then the minute it's over, I want to seep into the book-
Dr. John Schinnerer: Well- ...
Jeff Hatch: against
Dr. John Schinnerer: the wall And you want, you want to move them.
Jeff Hatch: Yes.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Yes That's what your story does. That's the point- Yes ... of your story. That's the weight, that's the, the [01:04:00] impact- Right ... of your story. Right That's why you tell it. 'Cause I don't... I, I did a radio show f- tw- ooh, 20 years ago.
Holy shit. Anyway, 20 years ago. And um, I remember at first I was just, like, reading about research studies, so I was just approaching people intellectually, and great research studies, great research, great tools, but I don't think it motivated anyone to do a damn thing.
Jeff Hatch: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Dr. John Schinnerer: And so I was like, "Oh, I gotta get better at storytelling and emoting."
And that's how we leave an impact on people. For sure. That's how we change behavior. 100%. So that's exactly what your story does, so it's this weird paradox within us- Mm-hmm ... of, wow, I just told a great story. I impacted a room full of people, and now I'm really uncomfortable when they tell me I just told a great story and I'm, uh, impacted a room full of people.
Like, what is up with that?
Jeff Hatch: Yeah. Yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: You know what I mean?
Jeff Hatch: Yes, I do. And I
Dr. John Schinnerer: think-
Jeff Hatch: I, yes ...
Dr. John Schinnerer: that's being human, which, you know, pisses me off a lot.
Jeff Hatch: I know, me too.
Dr. John Schinnerer: I know. My own humanity, you know? I- Come
Jeff Hatch: on ...
Dr. John Schinnerer: fuck, I lost my temper. Motherfu- [01:05:00]
Jeff Hatch: I know.
Dr. John Schinnerer: I mean, Joree used to say it when, I mean, when, when we would get in arguments.
We don't really argue much now, but we would get in an argument now and then. She'd be like, "Come on, you teach this stuff."
Jeff Hatch: Gosh, right?
Dr. John Schinnerer: I was like, "Honey, that's not helping."
Jeff Hatch: That's not what I need. I know, I know. I'm so with you though. I feel the same way, right? Like, I, I can't always be
Dr. John Schinnerer: the- Fine-tuning communication, you know?
Jeff Hatch: Yes, yes. Yes, yes, yes.
Closing and Where to Find Him
Dr. John Schinnerer: Oh my God, I, I'm, I just became aware of time. Um, time has flown by. This has been a fantastic conversation. Thank you so much.
Jeff Hatch: I don't even know what time it is, so yeah, thank you.
Dr. John Schinnerer: It's, yeah, it's been an hour-ish. So- Okay, great ... uh, let me ask you this. How can people find you? Give us the name of the books.
Um, what's the website? Sure. Whatever other information- Yeah ... you want to share.
Jeff Hatch: Yeah, the, the website I, I, I operate e- everything under is unbuiltmethod.com. Um, so you can find me there. You can find the book there. I have an app you can find there. Um, I've got a little merch brand that's Authenticity is Everything.
You can find [01:06:00] that there. Um, my Instagram handle is oldkidhatch because I always want to maintain the wonder and- capacity for joy of being a kid I love that You know? Um, so it's Old Kid Hatch, unbuiltmethod.com. Those are the two best ways. Um, and you can find me there and, and there's a million ways to connect through that, so yeah.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Okay. Well, I... Thank you so much for coming on and sharing your story. I really appreciate it. I appreciate the, the vulnerability and the growth that you've done. Um, and it's, it, I think it's a great example of, for those of us who have tried to achieve our way out of our depression or our wounds or our, you know, shame, and it just doesn't work.
Jeff Hatch: Yeah. And John, thank you, man. Thank you for being you, for doing the work you do, for creating this space for us to have this conversation, and just for the connection. I, like, I really enjoy talking to other men who are, who are on the same path and who are doing this work, and like, you're a great representation of it, so I appreciate you, you, [01:07:00] you taking- Yeah
the time to speak with me.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Thank you so much. That's very meaningful. See, I'm working with, you know, sitting with the compliment.
Jeff Hatch: Nice job.
Dr. John Schinnerer: Thank you. All right, and that is it for this episode of The Evolved Caveman Podcast. By the way, feel free to check out the Proxi He, coaching for men, AI coaching for men at proximitycoaching.com/he.
You can get a seven-day free trial. You'll dig it. It'll change your life. Check it out. And until next time, this is Dr. John signing off.
